Guide To The Best Self-Tanners

The Best Self-Tanners

Science and beauty have teamed up to bring us a whole slew of self-tanning options to take us from drab to fab, without having to endure the sun’s crispifying rays.

We took tons of tanning sprays, gels, lotions and mousses for a spin, all in the name of bringing you the best in bronzing beauty. We also asked some self-tanning gurus—and some total tan-o-phobes—for their input. The general consensus? We’ll take the fabulous faux glow, but leave that trademark self-tanner stink, thank you very much. With that feedback in mind, we’re bringing you the tops in tanners—from glittery bronzers to glow-n-gos to build-a-tans, and even some stuff we’d never seen before.

For more top picks, check out our guides to swimwear, mascara, and sweat fighters.

Is something sold out? Please tell us.

Instant Self Tanners

Need some quick color?  These instant self-tanners will get you toasty-hued in no time.

Fake Bake Self Tanner For Face DuWop Revolotion SPF 15 Xen-Tan Mist
Fake Bake Self Tanner
$20

Fake Bake’s Self Tanner For Face comes out of the tube a rich, dark tan color, so there’s no way you’ll end up with an uneven, patchy tan.


DuWop Revolotion SPF 15
$28

True cosmetics aficionados know the DuWop brand for its award winning pout plumper Lip Venom. Now they’ve thrown their hats in the self-tan ring with DuWop Revolotion SPF 15 , a foundation-like formula that goes on sheer and slightly shimmery and also has SPF 15 for sun protection.


Xen-Tan Mist

$29

Xen-Tan has a bunch of different self-tanning formulas, all with the line’s signature olive undertones (this prevents that orangey hue dreaded by faux tan fearers). But of their Dark Tan family of products icon, the Xen-Tan Mist iconis the easiest to use and the hardest to goof up.


Gradual Self Tanners

If you’re new to self-tanning, or just want something gradual, these self-tanners take effect slowly and steadily.

Neutrogena Build-a-Tan lotion clinique self sun lotionEditor’s Pick Liz Earle Sun Shade Botanical Self-Tan Spray
Neutrogena Build-A-Tan Lotion
$10

If you’re a tad less confident in your fake bake application technique, take advantage of build-a-tan technology. You less experienced tan-in-a-tubers should start here and build up to the big guns.

Clinique Self Sun Body Lotion
$18.50

Clinique is famous for its clean, classic products, and Self-Sun Touch of Bronze Moisturizing Body Lotion iconis no exception. The feather-light formula is close in texture and spreadability to Clinique’s yellow moisturizer.


Liz Earle Botanical Self-Tan Spray
$31

Crisp, refreshing and packed with skin-friendly botanicals, Liz Earle Sun Shade Botanical Self-Tan Spray is like a spa date that ends in a suntan. With good-for-you ingredients like aloe vera, rosewood, vitamin E, and tree moss, Sun Shade couldn’t be more opposite of damaging UV rays.


Bronzing Self Tanners

Get the sun-kissed look, and keep a natural complexion, with these bronzing self tanners.

Sex Symbol Aerotan Instant Temporary Tanning Spray Too Faced Tanning Bed In A Tube Tarte Glam Gams Leg Bronzing Stick
Sex Symbol Aerotan Instant Temporary Tanning Spray
$15

If you’ve got a friend to fake tan with, there’s nothing better than Sex Symbol Aerotan Instant Temporary Tanning Spray. This glittery-glam aerosol can of self-tanner most closely replicates what you’d get in one of those fancy spray-tan booths, and once it’s on, it’s on for good—there’s little time for rubbing, blotting or blending.


Too Faced Tanning Bed In A Tube
$22.50

Too Faced Tanning Bed In A Tube definitely wins the prize for best packaging. This funky, shine-infused sunless tanner has the grooviest golden tube, complete with swirly flowers and a silhouette of a beachy beauty.


Tarte Glam Gams Leg Bronzing Stick
$30

A summer wardrobe stacked with short shorts and hiked hemlines calls for a little leg reinforcement. Get a gleam on your way out the door by slicking on Tarte Glam Gams Leg Bronzing Stick, a shimmery stick with a delivery method not unlike deodorant.


Innovative Self Tanners

Try something new and interesting with a tanning mitt, or nature-based ingredients.

Aveeno Continuous Radiance Moisturizing LotionBargain Buy Solerra’s eXmitt SunSauce Moisturizing Sunless Bronzer with Hemp
Aveeno Continuous Radiance Moisturizing Lotion
$14

The ingenious bottle for Aveeno’s Continuous Radiance Moisturizing Lotion is split right down the middle, with soy-based moisturizer in one chamber and tanning agents in the other. Customize the deepness of your tan by twisting a dial at the top.


Solerra Sunless Tanning Mitt
$24.95 for 5 reusable mitts

Hey, we all make mistakes, but with Solerra’s Sunless Tanning Mitt, tanning mistakes are few and far between. Solerra’s sunless tanner is built right into the moist mitt—slip your hand inside the protective plastic lining, rub on, and voila! There’s no need for immediate hand-washing, and there’s no mess to clean up.


SunSauce Moisturizing Sunless Bronzer with Hemp
$28

“Hemp” and “Silicone” don’t have the best connotations, but when combined in SunSauce Moisturizing Sunless Bronzer with Hemp, they’re a power couple not to be taken lightly. Arguably the smoothest sunless tanner we tested, SunSauce is ultra-creamy and delivered a deep tan after only one application.


SHOP self tanners

MORE self tanners »
Advertisement
More Like this on SheFinds:
Share