One Woman Reveals How Beauty Products Are Really "Tested"

Large Editorial Image


February 3, 2016

With so many beauty products on the market, most of us probably assume they were rigorously tested before appearing on the shelves of our local drugstore. Who hasn’t read 99% effective and assumed the product was perfectly safe with proven results?

While some beauty products certainly deliver everything they claim and more, experts say you may not always want to put your faith in so-called unbiased clinical trials that use real women to sample a product and provide feedback about its efficacy. “Sometimes the studies brands provide are done by outside companies and done well,” says one source, who asked to remain anonymous and is the founder of an indie skincare company. “But generally, even with the third-party, the beauty clinical trials are done with incredibly small sample sizes (think 6-10 testers) that are not statistically significant.”

And then there’s the question of just how much science was involved in the clinical trial, something you expect if the product in question promises fewer wrinkles or less hyperpigmentation.”Skincare research is often a disappointment,” says Dr. Ben Johnson, owner of Osmosis Skincare. “This is true primarily because the government considers such studies too trivial to spend money on (versus cancer, diabetes, etc.) and therefore the money must be spent by the skincare companies themselves.  Therein lies problem number two: very few products actually achieve real results and so there is not a lot of drive to spend a lot of money on objective tests that prove how well these products really work.”

The “default strategy,” Johnson explains, is to perform consumer feedback studies, something he says are not independent 99% of the time and/or simply consist of questionnaires. “While knowing that ‘97% of participants saw an improvement’ implies a 97% improvement in a skin condition, it is important to remember that most likely the improvement was mild or they would discuss how much improvement was actually seen,” Johnson says. “So the 97% number ends up being pretty meaningless. In addition, many results discuss improvements in moisture or luminosity, which are not really the targets for serious skincare junkies.  It is time we looked at measured changes using third party research labs and objective equipment. Those studies come along very rarely.”

If you want to know what a clinical trial is really like, just ask “Pearson,” a woman who was one of 70 in a skincare study, but asked to keep her identity and the identity of the company anonymous. Pearson says she was given the product and agreed to four photo shoots for a total of $400 compensation ($100 per session). After being told she had the best results of all the participants, she was asked to shoot an additional video for an infomercial for $150 compensation.

And then things became slightly questionable. She describes the sessions as “grueling,” and says great pains were taken to ensure lighting, backgrounds, angles and distance were equal while photographing the women during various stages of using the product. “I saw slight changes, but not too dramatic, but the producers thought the results were amazing,” Pearson says. “They showed me photos that did show a difference, though the after photos looked a little lighter, which seemed odd since they had really seemed to make sure all elements were equal.”

Pearson admits her comments about the product on-camera weren’t always her own either. “When I did the infomercial, the producer basically fed me lines, which I didn’t appreciate, but I wanted them to get their good infomercial and I would have felt guilty not to go along with it,” she says. “He’d say things like, ‘Tell me how you were disappointed in other products that didn’t perform as promised.’ I had never told him about any previous experiences with other products. He also said things like, ‘Use the word wrinkles, not lines, and keep saying your age.’ When I remarked that my wrinkles looked ‘airbrushed away,’ he told me to not say that because people would think they were indeed Photoshopped, so he said, use, ‘erased.'”

None of this is to say that the companies you love are being dishonest with their clinical study claims, but it would be in everyone’s favor if more funding was provided to perform real scientific research on products, particularly those that claim they can improve skin conditions. The most reliable indicator of a product’s effectiveness may really be impartial online reviews–just another reason to love Makeup Alley.

For more beauty news and tips check out the shocking truth about the medical risk you take every time you use a new beauty product and everything you need to know about the EOS lawsuit.

 

Tags:

Beauty
  • Try This Simple Meditation Technique Tonight #WellnessWednesday

    Try This Simple Meditation Technique Tonight #WellnessWednesday

    Beauty

    today

  • H&M Sale Items Are An Extra 25% Off Today Only--Get These Flattering Jeans For Just $18 Before They're Gone!

    H&M Sale Items Are An Extra 25% Off Today Only--Get These Flattering Jeans For Just $18 Before They're Gone!

    Style

    today

  • 4

    4 "Super Foods" You Need In Your Diet #WellnessWednesday

    Beauty

    today

  • 6 Paula's Choice Products Every Woman Should Own

    6 Paula's Choice Products Every Woman Should Own

    Beauty

    today

  • Once And For All, Here's How To Remove Yellow Stains From The Underarms Of White Shirts #SHEfindsSolutions

    Once And For All, Here's How To Remove Yellow Stains From The Underarms Of White Shirts #SHEfindsSolutions

    Style

    1 day

  • Kendra Scott's Fall Collection Just Dropped And You're Going To Want Everything

    Kendra Scott's Fall Collection Just Dropped And You're Going To Want Everything

    Style

    1 day

  • This Under-The-Radar Brand Makes The Best Leggings Ever

    This Under-The-Radar Brand Makes The Best Leggings Ever

    Style

    1 day

  • The KKW Beauty Powder Contour Palette Is Finally Here & We're Freaking Out!

    The KKW Beauty Powder Contour Palette Is Finally Here & We're Freaking Out!

    Beauty

    1 day

  • Beauty Launches That NEED To Be On Your Radar This Month

    Kendra Scott's new gem-inspired fall nail polishes are gorgeous! Check them out.

    Beauty

    1 day

  • Psst! Now Is The Time To Stock Up On Cute Shorts Under $25

    Psst! Now Is The Time To Stock Up On Cute Shorts Under $25

    Style

    1 day

  • This $7 Liquid Eyeliner Creates The Perfect Cat Eye And Legit Lasts <em>All. Day.</em>

    This $7 Liquid Eyeliner Creates The Perfect Cat Eye And Legit Lasts All. Day.

    Beauty

    1 day

  • Use These Tricks To Make Your Nails Dry Faster #SHEfindsSolutions

    Use These Tricks To Make Your Nails Dry Faster #SHEfindsSolutions

    Beauty

    1 day

  • Clinique's New CliniqueFIT Collection Will Make You Actually Want To Workout

    Clinique's New CliniqueFIT Collection Will Make You Actually Want To Workout

    Beauty

    2 days

  • We Finally Found The Best Yoga Leggings, So You Can Stop Looking!

    We Finally Found The Best Yoga Leggings, So You Can Stop Looking!

    Shop

    2 days

  • Check Out These Pretty Maxi Dresses We Found--They're All $30 Or Less

    Check Out These Pretty Maxi Dresses We Found--They're All $30 Or Less

    Style

    2 days

  • Don't Wait Until Fall--Buy These Cute Rain Boots While They're On Sale For Just $39 Right Now

    Don't Wait Until Fall--Buy These Cute Rain Boots While They're On Sale For Just $39 Right Now

    Style

    2 days

  • Lululemon Sneakers Are Here & You're Going To Want Them All

    Lululemon Sneakers Are Here & You're Going To Want Them All

    Style

    3 days

  • Psst! These $13 Tops Are Selling Out Super Fast At Anthropologie's Huge Sale On Sale

    Psst! These $13 Tops Are Selling Out Super Fast At Anthropologie's Huge Sale On Sale

    Style

    3 days

  • Nordstrom Shoppers <em>Love</em> These $39 Skinny Jeans--Get A Pair Before They're Gone!

    Nordstrom Shoppers Love These $39 Skinny Jeans--Get A Pair Before They're Gone!

    Style

    3 days

  • It's #SampleSaturday And We're Giving Away 50 Moisturizers From Kate Somerville!

    It's #SampleSaturday And We're Giving Away 50 Moisturizers From Kate Somerville!

    Beauty

    4 days

  • This Silicone Beauty Sponge Is A Total Game-Changer

    This Silicone Beauty Sponge Is A Total Game-Changer

    Beauty

    4 days

  • Once And For All, Here's How To Stop A Hangnail From Getting Worse #SHEfindsSolutions

    Once And For All, Here's How To Stop A Hangnail From Getting Worse #SHEfindsSolutions

    Beauty

    4 days

  • Nordstrom Has So Many Cute, Cheap Finds Under $26 Right Now--Don't Miss These Deals!

    Nordstrom Has So Many Cute, Cheap Finds Under $26 Right Now--Don't Miss These Deals!

    Style

    5 days

  • Dermalogica's Daily Microfoliant Is The Best Exfoliator For Women With Dry Skin

    Dermalogica's Daily Microfoliant Is The Best Exfoliator For Women With Dry Skin

    Beauty

    5 days

  • The Perfect Summer-To-Fall Transition Dress Is On Sale For Just $35 At Zappos Right Now

    The Perfect Summer-To-Fall Transition Dress Is On Sale For Just $35 At Zappos Right Now

    Style

    5 days

  • Pin These Pretty Side Part Hairstyle Ideas For Those Days When You Need Simple Hair Inspo

    Pin These Pretty Side Part Hairstyle Ideas For Those Days When You Need Simple Hair Inspo

    Beauty

    5 days

  • Use Our Exclusive Promo Code To Get 30% Off The Allure x Case-Mate Selfie Case

    Use Our Exclusive Promo Code To Get 30% Off The Allure x Case-Mate Selfie Case

    Shop

    5 days

  • Sneak Peek! Here's Your First Look At A New Day, One Of The Awesome New Brands Coming To Target For Fall

    Sneak Peek! Here's Your First Look At A New Day, One Of The Awesome New Brands Coming To Target For Fall

    Style

    5 days

  • Get Winky Lux's Brand New Mini Lip Pill Kit For Only $12 With Our Exclusive Promo Code

    Get Winky Lux's Brand New Mini Lip Pill Kit For Only $12 With Our Exclusive Promo Code

    Beauty

    5 days

  • Weekend Project: Make Your Own Soothing Cuticle Cream

    Weekend Project: Make Your Own Soothing Cuticle Cream

    Beauty

    5 days

  • Love Your Legs? Show Them Off In An Asymmetric Hem Dress This Summer

    Love Your Legs? Show Them Off In An Asymmetric Hem Dress This Summer

    Style

    5 days

  • How To Clean Makeup Brushes

    How To Clean Makeup Brushes

    Beauty

    today

  • Hold Up -- Kylie Jenner Had A Nude Ice Sculpture Of Herself At Her Birthday Party?

    Hold Up -- Kylie Jenner Had A Nude Ice Sculpture Of Herself At Her Birthday Party?

    Celebrity

    today

  • 7 Times Celebs With Big Boobs Didn't Feel Like Wearing Bras & Were Still Total #FashionGoals

    7 Times Celebs With Big Boobs Didn't Feel Like Wearing Bras & Were Still Total #FashionGoals

    Celebrity

    today

  • Emma Stone Is The World's Highest-Paid Actress -- And You'll Never Guess How Much She Gets Paid

    Emma Stone Is The World's Highest-Paid Actress -- And You'll Never Guess How Much She Gets Paid

    Celebrity

    today

  • 4 All-Natural Supplements Dermatologists Swear By For Your Hair, Skin And Nails

    4 All-Natural Supplements Dermatologists Swear By For Your Hair, Skin And Nails

    Beauty

    today

  • Nicki Minaj Is Releasing New Lipsticks With A Cult-Favorite Brand!

    Nicki Minaj Is Releasing New Lipsticks With A Cult-Favorite Brand!

    Beauty

    today

  • Here's Everything You Need To DIY A “Backpack Kid” Halloween Costume

    Here's Everything You Need To DIY A “Backpack Kid” Halloween Costume

    Style

    today

  • The One Rodan & Fields Product Every Woman With Sunspots Should Own

    The One Rodan & Fields Product Every Woman With Sunspots Should Own

    Beauty

    today

  • 4 Things You Should Never Do At Nordstrom, According To People Who Work There

    4 Things You Should Never Do At Nordstrom, According To People Who Work There

    Shop

    today

  • Victoria Beckham Reveals What Makes Her 'Emotional' On Instagram, See The Heartbreaking Post Here!

    Victoria Beckham Reveals What Makes Her 'Emotional' On Instagram, See The Heartbreaking Post Here!

    Celebrity

    today

  • Here's How To DIY A Gigi and Bella Hadid Halloween Costume

    Here's How To DIY A Gigi and Bella Hadid Halloween Costume

    Celebrity

    today

  • Here's What You'll Need For The Perfect Ariana Grande Dangerous Woman Halloween Costume

    Here's What You'll Need For The Perfect Ariana Grande Dangerous Woman Halloween Costume

    Style

    today

  • In Need Of Some Skin Therapy? Rodan + Fields Is Here To Help!

    In Need Of Some Skin Therapy? Rodan + Fields Is Here To Help!

    Beauty

    today

  • What Is Pippa Middleton Wearing? She’s Practically Naked!

    What Is Pippa Middleton Wearing? She’s Practically Naked!

    Celebrity

    1 day

  • The One Top Trend You’re About To See Everywhere This Fall

    The One Top Trend You’re About To See Everywhere This Fall

    Style

    1 day

  • JAY-Z FINALLY Talked About His Elevator Fight With Solange Knowles, We Can't Believe What He Said About Her!

    JAY-Z FINALLY Talked About His Elevator Fight With Solange Knowles, We Can't Believe What He Said About Her!

    Celebrity

    1 day

  • 4 Concealer Hacks Every Woman Over 30 Needs To Know

    4 Concealer Hacks Every Woman Over 30 Needs To Know

    Beauty

    1 day

  • Every Fashion Girl Will Be Wearing This Zara Jacket This Fall

    Every Fashion Girl Will Be Wearing This Zara Jacket This Fall

    Style

    1 day

  • Here's Exactly What To Buy Your Kids For Back-To-School (This Stuff Is So Cool!)

    Here's Exactly What To Buy Your Kids For Back-To-School (This Stuff Is So Cool!)

    Shop

    1 day

  • How To Clean Suede

    How To Clean Suede

    Style

    1 day

  • 7 Celebs With Big Boobs Who Aren't Afraid To Wear See-Thru Outfits

    7 Celebs With Big Boobs Who Aren't Afraid To Wear See-Thru Outfits

    Celebrity

    1 day

  • The One Bad Thing About Dating Selena Gomez, According To Her Famous Ex

    The One Bad Thing About Dating Selena Gomez, According To Her Famous Ex

    Celebrity

    1 day