7 Tips for Cooking the Best Crab Cakes

August 4, 2015 by Martha Stewart
shefinds | Style

Love crab cakes but too intimidated to make your own? Here are 7 tips from our food editor Shira Bocar that will guarantee success.


Food editor Shira Bocar has perfected the classic summer dish (click here for her recipe) and has strong opinions about what makes a good, tender crab cake. Curious?

  1. Start with the freshest crabmeat you can find. Shira and her husband go crabbing and steam their catch as soon as they’re back on land, but you can get quality crabmeat at a store, too. “Just make sure you go to a reputable market and check with the fishmonger about the freshness of the crabs.”
  2. Go heavy on the lump meat. The large chunks of meat that come from the crab’s body are more succulent than the leg meat. Shira likes to use all lump meat in her crab cakes.
  3. Add mayonnaise. All crab cakes need something to bind the ingredients together. Shira has experimented with egg, mayonnaise, and a combination of the two. The winner: “I like to use just mayonnaise. It offers flavor and a nice amount of fat.”
  4. Crush up some oyster crackers. In lieu of soda crackers or breadcrumbs for the starch component, she uses crushed-up oyster crackers. “Their subtle saltiness plays along nicely with crab. I like my crab cakes to taste crabby.”
  5. Kick it up with mustard. Along with Worcestershire sauce (a flavor-boosting all-star), add mustard to the crab mixture for a hit of tanginess.
  6. Don’t overmix. In fact, “keep the lump meat as whole as possible. I like to mix everything else, then fold in the crab meat.”
  7. Skip the breading. A lot of recipes call for coating the cakes with breadcrumbs before frying them. “That coating, I think, interferes with the fresh crab flavor. I just put the cakes directly on a nice, heavy-bottom skillet, preheated with vegetable oil.”

More from Martha Stewart:

Quick, One-Pot Meal Ideas To Feed the Whole Family

45 Meatless Meals for a Healthy Dinner

36 Dinners You Can Make in Just 15 Minutes!

10 Grown Up Grilled Cheese Sandwiches


From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


Every Woman *Needs* This Under-$30 Blouse For Work--It's So Chic And Flattering

Want to step your office style up this season? Invest ...


The Perfect Fall Sweater Was Just Re-Stocked... And It's Only $23

Who's ready for sweater weather? Me! Me! While I ...


I'm Obsessed With Dia&Co, The Styling Service Exclusively For Women Sizes 14-32

Need a closet refresh for fall? You could go store ...


Take $25 Off Everything You Need For Fall At EILEEN FISHER Right Now

Summer was wonderful, but I'll say it so you ...


Need A Cute Dress To Wear On Repeat All Fall And Winter Long? We Found It For You

Just because summer is almost over doesn't mean you ...