What: Maybelline Define-A-Lash, $7
Why: Maybelline Great Lash may be "America's number one mascara," but the company's excellent new Define-A-Lash is set to stage an overthrow. Its tough, spiny brush–while sort of scary at first use–assures a clump-free application and a long, clean look for your lashes. The nifty green color of the tube is an added plus. Allure magazine granted Maybelline's Define-A-Lash this year's Editors' Choice award–and if they love it, so will you. Comes in very black, soft black, and blackish brown.
Get Yours: Drugstore.com
For more great mascara recommendations, see our guide to the best way to lengthen, thicken, and otherwise enhance your lashes.