Hands Down, These Are The Best Eye Creams Starting At Just $19.99 (Yes, Really!)

October 15, 2019 by Jeanine Edwards
shefinds | beauty

If you want your under-eye area to look smooth and youthful later, the key is start using a good eye cream now. But what exactly makes a good eye cream? Anti-aging properties are important, but so are sun protection, hydration and the absence of any irritation whatsoever.

If you’re not feeling up to the task of hunting down the best eye cream, no worries; we did it for you! Shop the best eye creams starting at just $19.99 below.

The Best Eye Creams

Shoppers Choice:

LilyAna Eye Cream Moisturizer

Highlights: Under $20; brightens, firms, hydrates, lifts and tightens; contains no parabens, artificial colors or artificial fragrances; vegan friendly; cruelty free;

“Incredible product! Still cannot believe what a difference it has made in the lines and wrinkles around my eyes. I use it twice a day, and actually use it for my entire face and my neck. My skin feels so soft, and lines are disappearing.” – Melissa

Buy from Amazon >>

Editor’s Picks:

Tatcha The Silk Peony Melting Eye Cream

Highlights: Reduces the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles; contains antioxidants that help protect against signs of future damage; cruelty-free and gluten-free; formulated with liquid silk and moisture-locking Japanese white peony for youthful-looking, radiant eyes

“I hate when I end up loving products that are pricey, but this is too good not to. It melts into your skin and gives your under-eye area the perfect amount of hydration.”Alisha

Buy from Amazon >>

Origins A Perfect World SPF 20 Age-Defense Eye Cream with White Tea

Highlights: 100% mineral SPF helps protect from UVA/UVB damage; formulated with antioxidants to help protect from IR, ground level ozone and pollution; oil-free; renews and brightens under eyes

“I love this stuff! It’s great for daytime, it’s not too heavy but definitely moisturizing, and I love the extra SPF for the delicate undereye area.” – Morgan

Buy from Amazon >>

Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado

Highlights: Effective for all skin types; uniquely-concentrated formula that won’t migrate under makeup; ophthalmologist- and dermatologist-tested; formulated with beta-carotene, shea butter and avocado oil for maximum hydration

“I’ve been using Kiehl’s avocado under eye treatment since high school. Hopefully It will keep me looking young forever! It’s so creamy and divine.”Justine

Buy from Amazon >>

Beautycounter Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream

Highlights: Formulated with “clean” plant-derived super-ingredients; reduces the appearance of under-eye shadows and crow’s feet; decreases puffiness

“I didn’t believe eye cream really did anything until I tried this one. Not only does it keep the area around my eyes soft and nourished, but it also brightens the area so my dark circles are significantly less noticeable. My eyes are also really sensitive and this ‘clean’ eye cream never causes any irritation or redness. I use it twice and day religiously now.”Jeanine (Read more about why I love this eye cream here.)

Buy from Beautycounter >>

SheFinds receives commissions for purchases made through the links in this post.


Vice President
Jeanine Edwards is a writer and editor covering fashion, beauty and shopping. She never misses a sale and is committed to good skincare. Prior to joining the SheFinds team, Jeanine worked at XO Group and InStyle. You can reach Jeanine at [email protected]

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


Believe It! All Of These Amazing Beauty Gift Sets Are $25 Or Less

I am pretty serious when it comes to gifting. I ...


12 Gift Ideas For Everyone On Your Holiday List

The holidays are right around the corner, and that means ...


This Super Nourishing Treatment Is Like A Green Juice For Your Hair

As a woman with really dry, curly hair, I'm ...


These Are The Best Blushes, Starting At Just $4.99 (You're Welcome!)

While concealer and mascara get all the glory, blush is ...


These Are The Best Body Washes That Leave Your Skin Clean, Soft And Smooth

If you're like most people, chances are you're ...


This Eyelash And Eyebrow Enhancer Serum Works In Just 4 Weeks--See The Before And After Pics!

Despite the growing popularity of eyelash extensions and procedures like ...


This Is The Safe (And Affordable!) Way To Get A Straighter Smile

If there's one thing we should all do more ...


Living Proof's Nourishing Hair Oil Keeps My Dry Hair Super Soft During The Winter

Most women know that their skin requires a bit more ...