FYI, These Are The Best Eyeliners According To Editors And Real Women Alike

November 12, 2019 by Jeanine Edwards
shefinds | beauty

If you’ve been on what seems like a never-ending hunt for the perfect eyeliner to create all those cool looks you see on Pinterest and Instagram, the search ends here. We been busy testing under-the-radar and raved-about eyeliners alike, all in hopes of identifying the absolute best buys.

After months of drawing more cat-eyes and wings than we’d like to admit, the results are finally in. These are the best eyeliners you need in your life ASAP.

The Best Eyeliners

Shoppers Choice:

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Highlights: Waterproof; enables you to create a variety of eye-opening effects; formula glides on with ease, dries quickly and won’t smudge or run; marker-like tip offers precise application for everyone from novices to pros

“I literally just received this eye liner in the mail, tried it on, and had to write a review! Awesome product, buy it now. Very dark, very easy to put on (nice sharp point) and I’m a very happy customer. I have not, however, spent a day with this on my lids to see how it holds up, or tried to get it off( I usually wash with the oil cleansing method so I don’t anticipate any trouble getting the liner off) so I will have to get back to you on those situations….but if you want a precise, clean, dark and fabulous cat eye, this is the liner for you.

UPDATE: Ok, after a one hour long Body Combat class in the middle of summer in a crowded room with hardly any air-conditioning I was VERY curious to see how this eyeliner would hold up. At the end of the class I checked it out and there was NO smudging or flaking. That is seriously impressive! “ – Taylor

Buy from Amazon >>

Buy from Sephora >>

Editor’s Picks:

L’Oreal Paris Makeup Flash Cat Eye by Infallible, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Highlights: Waterproof formula; comes with easy-to-use removable wing stencil; under $10

“I rarely use eyeliner so I don’t like to buy ones that cost a fortune. But when I do grab for one, I always go to this liquid eyeliner from L’Oreal. Not only does it stay all day but it also comes with a stencil to achieve the perfect winged liner.”Alisha

Buy from Amazon >>

bareminerals One Fine Line Micro Precision Eyeliner

Highlights: Long lasting eyeliner formula is waterproof and smudge-proof; made with naturally-derived waxes to enable the pencil to glide on without dragging or tugging

“I love how smoothly this eyeliner glides on. I usually have a pretty unsteady hand when I’m doing my makeup in the morning, but the thin tip on this eyeliner makes it so easy to get a thin, straight line right at the lash line. This is my go-to eyeliner whenever I want to do a cute little cat-eye look.”Jeanine (Read more about why I love this eyeliner here)

Buy from Amazon >>

Buy from Nordstrom >>

Urban Decay Perversion Waterproof Fine Point Eye Pen

Highlights: Ultimate brush and a cartridge system that allows for a constant flow of ink for the smoothest application; ultra fine tip glides on smooth without skipping or pulling; cruelty-free

“The best eyeliner is Urban Decay’s Perversion. It’s waterproof and has a fine-point end so you can create the most perfect cat-eye EVER (even if you’re a beginner like myself!).”Justine

Buy from Amazon >>

Maybelline Lasting Drama Matte Lacquer Eyeliner

Highlights: Gel eyeliner; delivers a bold matte finish; phthalate-free

“I am HOOKED on this eyeliner. I love the brush it comes with, too. It’s a great consistency and I prefer the matte look it dries as. The brush helps me get a good wing but it’s great for just lining the top of your eye as well.” Morgan

Buy from Target >>

MAC Technakohl Liner

Highlights: Mechanical pencil-style liner; goes on soft and creamy; dries quickly for long-wear

“I really like this one because it’s really easy to control and get the line I want. I use the Deep Chocolate Brown color, which is perfect for every day.”Hannah

 Buy from Amazon >>

SheFinds receives commissions for purchases made through the links in this post.


Vice President
Jeanine Edwards is a writer and editor covering fashion, beauty and shopping. She never misses a sale and is committed to good skincare. Prior to joining the SheFinds team, Jeanine worked at XO Group and InStyle. You can reach Jeanine at [email protected]

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


They're Here! Shop This Year's Best Gifts That Give Back

Want your holiday gifts to go the extra mile this ...


Shoppers--And SheFinds Editors!--Really *Love* These Bestselling Candles

Not sure what candle you should try next? We're ...