Carrie Underwood Fans Flood American Idol’s Instagram Page After They Didn’t Confirm Her Return For The New Season: ‘Katy Did Not Seem Genuine, Carrie Does’

Carrie Underwood's Fans Want Her To Come Back For Another Season

"I hope Carrie comes back," commented one fan. "Yay! Please make sure Carrie is a judge next season! She is super fun!! Love her so much!," exclaimed a second, followed by the red heart emoji. "@carrieunderwood I hope you're coming back for the next season," wrote a third.

"I think this has been my favorite season! The contestants are all so genuine and immensely talented! Carrie has brought a more wholesome aspect to the show as well," noted a fourth, as a fifth suggested that the former American Idol winner was a better judge than the "Roar" hitmaker, writing: "I actually hope Carrie returns, she has been a breath of fresh air, I feel she is [better] than Katy, Katy did not seem genuine, Carrie does."

"I'm back if @carrieunderwood is back! She gets along so well with Luke and Lionel," wrote a sixth fan, as a seventh also thought Carrie has been a "breath of fresh air." The same fan added: "Honest and supportive, humble and talented. Plus, she brought us 'faith night.' Good choice, and I hope all 3 come back."

"I pray that @CarrieUnderwood returns as a judge. She was a great addition to the judges panel this season," wrote another hopeful fan, as someone else said the new season "must have Carrie." "I will be back if Carrie is back!" stated another fan, followed by the fire, red heart, and heart eyes emojis.