Why: So many fancy sugar cookies taste like paste, but these adorable shapes from Truly Scrumptious are anything but. They’re fresh baked, so they taste great and they’re beautifully designed and decorated. These tasty bites make ideal baby shower favors or a sweet gift for a new mom. We’re partial to the onesie design, but there are several other shapes to choose from. You can even work with the baker to create your own custom cookie shape!
Price: $36 for 12