What: Essie Soul Mate Nail Polish, $7
Why: We love the idea of dark polish. But it's the actual practice of using it that's got us stumped. Take away the problem of a darker color making mistakes more obvious, and you've still got the problem of going one shade too dark and coming out Goth.
Good thing the SheFinds readers are more in-the-know than we are! We found a great recommendation for Essie Soul Mate, and now we're ready to take the plunge. The plum shade, which is perfect with Fall trends, looks just dark enough to add a bit of a fashion edge without crossing the line into freaky. And, as Born2Shop points out, it's not right for you, a couple swipes of remover gives you a blank canvas. At $7, we say this experiment is worth a try.
Get Yours: Beautybay.com