Style

Recession Beauty: I Got My Mascara At The Drugstore... But You Can't Tell

August 6, 2008 by SheFindsSuzelle
shefinds | Style

Here at SheFinds, we’re feeling the economic pinch as much as the next beauty product addict. And so we’re bringing you new weekly picks that won't empty your wallet. We’ll test products and let you know how they hold up… hopefully saving you money by finding a cheaper version of the products you love and saving you from wasting your precious dough on a no-good knock-off.

 

Up first, mascara.

 

I compared four products and one was a clear winner, though all would have earned a place in my make-up bag for weekly wear. And I’m picky about mascara. I have long lashes that need a volumizing oomph and I wear contacts, which means I stay away from anything that flakes.

 

So, the winner: CoverGirl Lash Exact ($7.39). The secret is in the plastic brush, which keeps lashes from clumping, even after multiple applications. It volumizes and lengthens without looking fake. It wipes off easily, doesn't smudge and this baby never flakes.

 

 

First Runner Up: Maybelline Great Lash ($4.49). This one is an Allure Best of Beauty winner, but it’s No. 2 in my book simply because it gets clumpy a little faster than the CoverGirl Exact Lash. But, it goes on evenly and is good for sensitive eyes.

Maybelline mascara  

Second Runner Up: Wet n’ Wild Mega Protein ($2). The price is right for this drug store brand staple, but the chunks put it a distant third. One application isn’t enough, but two gets thick… especially after you’ve been using it for a week. But I'll give it you, this stuff doesn't smudge!

Wet n' Wild mascara  

Last Place: Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes ($18). Lengthen, curl and volumize your lashes… and know that you spent too much on mascara. It absolutely works and probably stays clump free longer than any of the other three brands I tested… but for the price of one tube I can get a years’ worth of my favorite CoverGirl.

Tarte mascara  

Do you have a favorite budget beauty product we should profile? Let us know in our comments section below!

Author:

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

Fashion

Don't Let Summer Pass By Without Buying One Of These 5 Denim Dresses

The only denim you'll catch our editors wearing this ...

Fashion

These Are The 6 Essential Dresses *Every* Woman Should Own

The key to effortless style, no matter the season? Stocking ...

Fashion

Every Woman Should Own This $35 Midi Dress--It Makes You Look *So* Good

I'm a firm believer in self-love and -confidence ...

Fashion

Drop What You're Doing! Nordstrom Has Outdoor Voices Leggings On Sale For 50% Off Right Now

Nordstrom's Anniversary sale may be starting later this week, ...

Fashion

This Is The Lightweight, Hands-Free Bag Every Woman Should Be Carrying This Summer

Remember when crossbody bags blew up a few years back? ...

Fashion

7 Linen Pieces You'll Want To Live In All Season Long

When the forecast is 90 degrees+, the last thing you ...

Fashion

Psst! You *Need* This $20 Nordstrom Top In Your Summer Wardrobe

It's not every day that you can get clothing ...

Fashion

This Is The One Dress *Every* Woman Should Own For Special Occasions

One of the things I love most about summer? All ...

LOAD MORE
+
LOAD MORE POSTS