Every girl loves an occasion to wear something sparkly, and what better reason is there than ringing in the New Year? Both of these funky chartreuse and black numbers have glistening hemlines and no shortage of short-dress sass.

But one of these green dresses will cost you quite a bit of green (try $300) while the other will set you back only a third of that ($96). Which holiday-ready frock is a sequined steal: the one with burnout roses and a pretty pailette border, or the one with a smattering of onyx-hued rhinestones and a hippy take on giraffe print? Take our Taste Test and find out:

Test your shopping intelligence with other Taste Tests.