What Happens When Boots Are Advertised As 'Good For Wide Calves' But They're Not?

November 12, 2014 by Justine Schwartz
shefinds | Shop
view slideshow

Finding boots to fit wide calves is hard enough, but when a boot is advertised as being “good for wide calves” in the product description and it still does not fit when you get it, it can be especially frustrating. I am right on the cusp of being able to wear regular boots, but I always go for “wide” ones because I’ve been burned in the past by boots that I loved online then couldn’t fit in to when they arrived at my doorstep. If you have wide or muscular calves, you understand my plight.

Eager not to have this happen again, I did an extensive search online of the boots that retailers like Zappos, DSW, Nordstrom and more have listed under the “Wide Calves” category. I read literally hundreds of customer reviews and ratings, and the results were surprising: around 50% of the boots in these sections had at least 1 negative customer review about fit (see the slideshow above for details).

In addition to negative reviews, I also found that Steve Madden, Frye and rsvp had consistently the best ratings for boots with wide calves (either their regular styles were generally more forgiving and easier to get on, or they offered wide calf versions that did not compromise the overall look and style of the boot). Retailers Zappos and 6pm offer an “extra wide calf” category that had almost no negative reviews–this is a fail-safe place to look for boots for wide calves, most are around 18″ wide.

Click through the slideshow for a sampling of the boots that are advertised as being good for wide calves, and the customer reviews that prove that they are indeed NOT. Are you listening, retailers?

[Photo: Damsel in Dior]



boots, shoes

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


This Cozy Sweater *Literally* Has Thousands Of Rave Reviews At Everlane

January 14, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
We want every color!


Celebrities Swear By These Super Slimming Leggings From Old Navy--& They're Only $32!

January 14, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
They're so affordable!


This Coat Is SO Flattering, No One Will Believe It Was Under $50!

January 13, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
We want one in every color!


You Need To Buy This $35 Jacket From Zara Before The Price Goes Back Up!

January 12, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
It's so chic!


We Never Expected To See Boots Like THIS But Now They’re A Huge Winter Trend

January 9, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
This is so new!


Once And For All, These Are The Best Bras To Buy If You Have Big Boobs

January 9, 2019 by Emily Belfiore
You're welcome in advanced!


Coach Is Having A 50% Off Sale Right Now--They're Practically Giving Away Free Bags!

January 5, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
These deals are too good!


This Trend Will Be EVERYWHERE in 2019--Just Wait & See!

January 5, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
We already love it!


Once And For All, These Are The Best Slimming Leggings Under $20 From Amazon

January 3, 2019 by Jessica Harrington
They're top rated!


5 Boot Trends Everyone Will Be Wearing In Winter 2019, According To Our Editors

December 30, 2018 by SHEfinds Editors
Add them to your cart ASAP!