X

Enter to win a FREE
Magnetight Mask
from Dr. Brandt!

*By entering to win, you agree to receive future emails from Dr. Brandt.

What Happens When Fashion Brands Sue Over Trademark Infringement?

Large Editorial Image


October 30, 2014

Just two weeks ago Converse filed a lawsuit against 31 companies, claiming that their iconic Chuck Taylor sneaker had been copied by brands like Ed Hardy, Walmart, H&M and more. The company, now owned by Nike, claims that copyright infringement has occurred as well as unfair competition (basically, when the customer can’t tell the difference between the fakes and the original). They are seeking compensation and also demanding that the retailers destroy all the imitation Chuck Taylors on the market. It’s a major case that comes on the heels of over 180 letters issued by Converse over the years asking retailers to stop knocking off their shoe.

Another copyright infringement case, also involving sneakers, has made headlines recently. New Balance filed a similar lawsuit against Karl Lagerfeld earlier this year, claiming that Lagerfeld’s leather suede mesh sneakers ($360) were so similar to their own 574 black sneakers ($112.88) that customers were mistaking them. Lagerfeld seemingly swapped out the ‘N’ for his own ‘K’. (We noticed the striking resemblance when we first saw the kicks, and our article was even referenced in court docs!) The case is still in court.

These lawsuits date back to the 1930s, when Madeleine Vionnet and Coco Chanel filed a suit in Paris against dressmaker Suzanne Laniel, claiming that she was copying their designs to sell to her clients. In this case, the French court ruled in favor of the two designers, stating that “the dress models, by reason of the choice of colors and materials and their designing, partake of the character of real works of art and therefore come under the special legislation which forbids imitation and plagiarism by artists and writers.”

And while the French courts protected early Chanel designs as “real works of art,” U.S. courts today take a very different approach. It is much more difficult to obtain a trademark here; clothing is seen as something utilitarian or as serving a functional purpose and therefore isn’t protected the same way a painting or piece of art would be. So, any of the components of the Chuck Taylor shoe that are considered functional (the sole, the toe cap), may not be protected under the terms of the trademark. It’s tricky.

So, does Converse have a case? In fashion, what crosses the line from imitation to an illegal knock-off? And if a finished piece of clothing can’t be trademarked, how can designers protect themselves and their designs? We took a closer look at a handful of these cases, in an effort to better understand all sides:

How Can Brands Protect Themselves From Knock-Offs?

Although Converse claims that they’ve owned trademarks to the design of the Chuck Taylor, it might not be a slam-dunk case. There are legal factors to consider—like, if the trademarks hold any validity and whether the court will agree that infringement has taken place (do the shoes really look identical?). Converse will have to convince the judge that shoppers are mistaking the knock-offs for the original Chuck Taylors in order to win.

Knockoffs and copies not only take away from a designer’s profit, but they can also devalue a product. Take, for example, Isabel Marant’s wedge sneaker. Since the sneaker first came out, there have been dozens of knock-offs made, and many of them could easily be mistaken for the real thing. So when a consumer has the option to get a pair of really good Marant knock-off wedges for under a hundred bucks, instead of shelling out over $300 for the real thing, the cheaper version wins out.

And generally, winning a trademark infringement case isn’t so easy. There’s a large pushback by many who oppose the concept of trademarking fashion designs, arguing that copying is what establishes trends, and that trends drive the fashion industry. This argument is part of the reason why trademarking laws are so thin for fashion designs. “Without copying, paradoxically, the fashion industry would be smaller and less innovative and poorer,” says Chris Sprigman, an NYU law professor in an interview with NPR.

So when does imitation cross that line into breaking the law? “The law basically says that elements of a design of a product—be it a shoe or anything else—that are functional cannot be protected by trademark law,” explains Sprigman in the same NPR article. Since an overall article of clothing is considered functional, it isn’t subject to copyright protection.

In regards to the Chuck Taylor, Sprigman goes on to say that the both the rubber bumper and toe cap were advertised as functional by the brand in the past, which basically leaves the stripes and the iconic star suitable for trademark protection.

Because an overall article of clothing is considered functional, copyright law can’t protect it. However, there are still steps a fashion designer can take to protect elements of their designs. They can register copyrights for original prints and patterns, innovative combinations, and unique color arrangements. They can also protect any conceptual elements of a design that can stand away from the functionality of an article of clothing.

In other words, if an element of a design can be identified as reflecting a designer’s artistic judgment that was executed independently of functional influence, and the concept of the design can be separated by the functionality, it can be protected by copyright. This is why patterns and textiles can be protected—they are seen as creative and independent of any functionality.

Colors can be trademarked, but only when the color uniquely identifies the origin of a product. So for Christian Louboutin, obtaining a trademark for his red soles was crucial—those red soles are what denote a Louboutin heel to consumers. We’ll get into the lawsuit he filed later on.

Designers that have created something that’s considered innovative and new can apply for a design patent, but only when the ornamental elements dominate the functional elements. Celine was granted design patents for the Diamond Clutch and the Case Bag. It makes sense for designers to apply for design patents when an item in their collection is meant to be a staple piece that will be reintroduced with more than a few collections. The same goes for an ornament that’s meant to be a trend-setter, like Alexander Wang’s studs. In 2011, the designer was granted a patent for the studs he created for the Rocco Bag.

Do Lawsuits Stop Knock-Offs?

So, does filing a lawsuit put an end do knock-offs? Not in the case of copy houses, like Forever21.  In many ways, Forever21’s business is built on knocking designers off. The company has been sued over 50 times by designers like Anna Sui and Diane von Furstenberg, but it hasn’t stopped them from continuing these practices, and likely never will. For a company that’s success depends on making cheap knock-offs of designer clothing, getting slapped with lawsuits just comes with the territory—it’s more than likely that settlement money is built into their budget (we’re just speculating)—but when a company is worth 3 billion dollars, coming up with the money to pay a fine is no big thing. “They go ahead and they take what they want, and when they get caught, they pay up. It’s probably cheaper than licensing it in the first place,” explains fashion legal expert Susan Scafidi in an article on Jezebel.

Can A Brand Be On Both Sides?

In the 90’s, Yves Saint Laurent filed a lawsuit against Ralph Lauren, claiming that the designer was knocking-off his ‘Le Smoking’ tuxedo suit. He charged Lauren with counterfeiting and disloyal competition. Saint Laurent won the case and was awarded $395,000 by Ralph Lauren.

But YSL doesn’t only play victim in these cases; in 2011, famed shoe designer Christian Louboutin filed a lawsuit against Yves Saint Laurent, accusing the designer of ripping off his trademarked red-soled heels. The judge initially ruled in favor of Saint Laurent on the grounds that Louboutin’s trademark was too broad, therefore not protectable. The court explained that fashion designers can obtain trademarks for a single color if the color is used in specific pattern or color combination, and that color is a basic element of fashion so it can’t be claimed by one designer.

But a color can be trademarked when it uniquely identifies the origin of the product, which is exactly what a red sole does for Louboutin’s shoes. So the designer appealed, and proved that his red sole is what distinguishes a Louboutin heel the same way Tiffany uses blue to distinguish their box from other jewelers. The court then rejected its earlier ruling, and stated that Louboutin was entitled to its trademark on red soles, except when the entire shoe is red. So Louboutin may have won, but technically Saint Laurent didn’t lose because the court ruled that his monochromatic red shoe did not infringe on any of Louboutin’s trademark rights.

What Is The Outcome Of Most Cases?

Only 5% of lawsuits actually make it to trial, and companies often settle before lawsuits go to trial to avoid the expense, which can often wind up costing more in both finances and bad publicity, even if they end up winning. Settling could likely be the way many of the brands that Converse is going after deal with the lawsuit, especially a company as huge as and wealthy as Walmart.

Such was the case for Steve Madden when both Alexander McQueen and Balenciaga sued him. Each of the two design houses filed a suit against Madden for knocking off a specific shoe. In McQueen’s case it was the Faithful bootie that was being knocked off, and for Balenciaga it was the Lego sandal. Madden settled both suits out of court, and paid each of the designers an undisclosed amount.

In 2011, Hermes went after LA-based accessories company Thursday Friday for silk-screening images of the Birkin onto canvas totes, accusing them of copyright infringement. Although the totes were meant as a parody, Hermes was not amused, and the case was settled.

Tory Burch and her ex-husband, the owner of C. Wonder, went through a long and messy lawsuit as they were in the midst of their divorce, which also ultimately ended up in settlement.

Being that Converse’s entire value as a brand is the iconic design of their sneakers, they need to protect that with everything they have; otherwise they cease to have any value whatsoever. For Converse, it’s all about brand recognition, and some of the copies can easily be mistaken for the real thing (Walmart, H&M). Converse may have a good chance at winning due to the near identical nature of these copies, so they could likely be able to prove that their trademark is as crucial as the Christian Louboutin red sole.

 

Tags:

lifestyle, News

Shop Converse Chuck Taylors

More Converse Chuck Taylors | 3 of 1011 »

PLAY Women's Converse Chuck Taylor Low Top by

Comme des Garcons

Buy Now

Converse® Chuck Taylor All Star High-Top Sneakers in Velvet by

Madewell

Buy Now

Chuck Taylor(R) High Top Sneaker by

Converse

Buy Now




  • Weekend Project: Make Your Own DIY Face Mask

    Weekend Project: Make Your Own DIY Face Mask

    Shop

    today

  • Nordstrom's Bestselling $27 Tunic Is Back In Stock--Grab One Quick Before It Sells Out Again

    Nordstrom's Bestselling $27 Tunic Is Back In Stock--Grab One Quick Before It Sells Out Again

    Style

    today

  • These Genius Packing Cubes Are A Game-Changer

    These Genius Packing Cubes Are A Game-Changer

    Shop

    today

  • These Are The Best Sites That Give You Cash Or Store Credit For New And Lightly-Worn Clothes

    These Are The Best Sites That Give You Cash Or Store Credit For New And Lightly-Worn Clothes

    Style

    today

  • Target Just Added 11 New Products To Your Favorite Brand This Morning

    Target Just Added 11 New Products To Your Favorite Brand This Morning

    Beauty

    today

  • Shoppers Can't Stop Raving About This All-In-One Home Security System

    Shoppers Can't Stop Raving About This All-In-One Home Security System

    Shop

    1 day

  • The 5 Best Stress-Relieving Items That You NEED In Your Life--From Fidget Spinners To Stress Balls.

    The 5 Best Stress-Relieving Items That You NEED In Your Life--From Fidget Spinners To Stress Balls.

    1 day

  • Forever 21 Is Making This Big Change To Its Stores

    Forever 21 Is Making This Big Change To Its Stores

    Beauty

    1 day

  • These Are The Best Collaborations You <em>Need</em> To Know About Now

    LeSportsac Just Launched An Adorable Collab With Hershey's

    Shop

    1 day

  • Here's How To Wear Metallic Booties Like A Style Blogger

    Here's How To Wear Metallic Booties Like A Style Blogger

    Shop

    1 day

  • 8 Galentine's Day Gifts That Are Perfect For The Lady Love In Your Life

    8 Galentine's Day Gifts That Are Perfect For The Lady Love In Your Life

    Style

    1 day

  • The One Dress That Looks Good On Everyone, According To Fashion Experts

    The One Dress That Looks Good On Everyone, According To Fashion Experts

    Style

    2 days

  • Target Just Casually Launched Its First Fragrance Line This Morning

    Target Just Casually Launched Its First Fragrance Line This Morning

    Beauty

    2 days

  • We Just Found The Most Amazing Pair Of Fleece Leggings Ever... And They're Only $19!

    We Just Found The Most Amazing Pair Of Fleece Leggings Ever... And They're Only $19!

    Style

    2 days

  • Psst! These Gorgeous (Waterproof!) Suede SOREL Booties Are 50% Off Right Now

    Psst! These Gorgeous (Waterproof!) Suede SOREL Booties Are 50% Off Right Now

    Style

    2 days

  • boohoo Is Having An <em>Epic</em> Sweater Sale Right Now--Prices Start At Just $16 With Our Exclusive Promo Code

    boohoo Is Having An Epic Sweater Sale Right Now--Prices Start At Just $16 With Our Exclusive Promo Code

    Style

    2 days

  • Beauty Pick Of The Week: Why I'm Obsessed Over The Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette

    Beauty Pick Of The Week: Why I'm Obsessed Over The Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette

    Beauty

    2 days

  • This Is The Most-Searched Fashion Trend Of 2017 (It's Not What You Think!)

    This Is The Most-Searched Fashion Trend Of 2017 (It's Not What You Think!)

    2 days

  • How Does Amazon's No-Rush Shipping Rewards Work? Here's Everything You Need To Know!

    How Does Amazon's No-Rush Shipping Rewards Work? Here's Everything You Need To Know!

    Shop

    2 days

  • Where To Buy Those Tiny Sunglasses Everyone Will Be Wearing In 2018

    Where To Buy Those Tiny Sunglasses Everyone Will Be Wearing In 2018

    2 days

  • 4 Skincare Products People With Clear Skin Always Use

    4 Skincare Products People With Clear Skin Always Use

    Beauty

    3 days

  • These Apps Will Help You Keep Your New Year's Resolutions #WellnessWednesday

    These Apps Will Help You Keep Your New Year's Resolutions #WellnessWednesday

    3 days

  • These Are The Best Leggings Ever (& They're Not See-Through!)

    These Are The Best Leggings Ever (& They're Not See-Through!)

    Style

    3 days

  • Here's Your Complete Guide To Sulfate-Free Beauty Products

    Here's Your Complete Guide To Sulfate-Free Beauty Products

    Beauty

    3 days

  • Here's Everything You Need to Know About Jade Rolling, The Hottest New Beauty Craze

    Here's Everything You Need to Know About Jade Rolling, The Hottest New Beauty Craze

    Beauty

    3 days

  • Want Glowing Skin When You Wake Up? Try This Overnight Mask From Dr. Brandt

    Want Glowing Skin When You Wake Up? Try This Overnight Mask From Dr. Brandt

    Beauty

    3 days

  • In Case You Hadn't Noticed, North Face x Nordstrom Just Dropped A Major Collab

    In Case You Hadn't Noticed, North Face x Nordstrom Just Dropped A Major Collab

    3 days

  • Don't Miss Your Chance To Score Ray-Bans For $79 At Nordstrom Rack Right Now

    Don't Miss Your Chance To Score Ray-Bans For $79 At Nordstrom Rack Right Now

    3 days

  • How To Clean White Reebok Classics So They Look Brand New

    How To Clean White Reebok Classics So They Look Brand New

    Style

    3 days

  • Target's New Line Doesn’t Launch Until February But We Have All The Photos

    Target's New Line Doesn’t Launch Until February But We Have All The Photos

    3 days

  • The One Foundation Every Woman Over 30 Should Use, According To A Dermatologist

    The One Foundation Every Woman Over 30 Should Use, According To A Dermatologist

    Beauty

    4 days

  • 5 Common Mistakes That Are Making Your Hair Thin, According To Experts

    5 Common Mistakes That Are Making Your Hair Thin, According To Experts

    Beauty

    today

  • 3 Cheap Products For Blackheads That Dermatologists Swear By

    3 Cheap Products For Blackheads That Dermatologists Swear By

    Beauty

    today

  • Um, How Bella Hadid Not Have A Wardrobe Malfunction In This See-Through Top?

    Um, How Bella Hadid Not Have A Wardrobe Malfunction In This See-Through Top?

    Celebrity

    1 day

  • 3 Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter Dupes That Are Just As Great As The Original

    3 Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter Dupes That Are Just As Great As The Original

    Beauty

    1 day

  • This Is The Worst Thing To Put On A Zit, According To A Dermatologist

    This Is The Worst Thing To Put On A Zit, According To A Dermatologist

    Beauty

    1 day

  • Scott Disick's New Girlfriend Is Trying Really Hard To Be Kourtney Kardashian

    Scott Disick's New Girlfriend Is Trying Really Hard To Be Kourtney Kardashian

    Celebrity

    1 day

  • 6 At-Home Remedies For Sagging Skin Dermatologists Swear By

    6 At-Home Remedies For Sagging Skin Dermatologists Swear By

    Beauty

    1 day

  • 5 Cheap Under-Eye Products Dermatologists Swear By

    5 Cheap Under-Eye Products Dermatologists Swear By

    Beauty

    1 day

  • 5 Cheap Natural Skin-Firming Products Dermatologists Swear By

    5 Cheap Natural Skin-Firming Products Dermatologists Swear By

    Beauty

    1 day

  • 4 Bedtime Mistakes That Are Ruining Your Skin, According Dermatologists

    4 Bedtime Mistakes That Are Ruining Your Skin, According Dermatologists

    Beauty

    2 days

  • This Clue Finally Proves That Kylie Jenner Is Pregnant

    This Clue Finally Proves That Kylie Jenner Is Pregnant

    Celebrity

    2 days

  • Um, What Was Kendall Jenner Thinking When She Wore This Outfit?

    Um, What Was Kendall Jenner Thinking When She Wore This Outfit?

    Celebrity

    2 days

  • Scarlett Johansson’s Got A New Boyfriend… And You’ve Definitely Seen Him Before

    Scarlett Johansson’s Got A New Boyfriend… And You’ve Definitely Seen Him Before

    Celebrity

    2 days

  • The One Cheap Natural Product Dermatologists Swear By For Blackheads

    The One Cheap Natural Product Dermatologists Swear By For Blackheads

    Beauty

    2 days

  • 5 Anti-Inflammatory Foods Experts Swear By To Look 10 Years Younger

    5 Anti-Inflammatory Foods Experts Swear By To Look 10 Years Younger

    Beauty

    2 days

  • 5 Cheap Natural Eye Creams Dermatologists Swear By For Under-Eye Bags

    5 Cheap Natural Eye Creams Dermatologists Swear By For Under-Eye Bags

    Beauty

    2 days

  • Um, Where Is Chrissy Teigen's Baby Bump?

    Um, Where Is Chrissy Teigen's Baby Bump?

    Celebrity

    2 days

  • Whoa! Are Miley Cyrus & Liam Hemsworth MARRIED?!

    Whoa! Are Miley Cyrus & Liam Hemsworth MARRIED?!

    Celebrity

    3 days

  • 4 Supplements You Should Take For Hair Loss, According To Dermatologists

    4 Supplements You Should Take For Hair Loss, According To Dermatologists

    Beauty

    3 days

  • Kylie Jenner Just Made The Most Amazing Announcement Ever & We're Freaking Out!

    Kylie Jenner Just Made The Most Amazing Announcement Ever & We're Freaking Out!

    Celebrity

    3 days

  • The One Concealer Mistake You Need To Stop Making, According To A Makeup Artist

    The One Concealer Mistake You Need To Stop Making, According To A Makeup Artist

    Beauty

    3 days

  • 7 Gorgeous Hair Trends Every Bride Will Want In 2018

    7 Gorgeous Hair Trends Every Bride Will Want In 2018

    Beauty

    4 days