These Are By Far The BEST Cropped Jeans I've Ever Owned

April 10, 2018 by Brianna Peters
shefinds | Fashion

The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants featured one pair of unique jeans that magically fit a group of four friends – all different shapes and sizes. While one single pair of jeans of the same size fitting multiple different women is highly unlikely, finding the best pair of cropped jeans that look great on everyone turned out to be less difficult.

Since its resurgence on the jean scene, I have been after the magical unicorn pair that is the best cropped jeans. Being only 5”4, I constantly had relationship issues with cigarette skinnies and flares for either not being short enough to accentuate my peekaboo ankles OR being too unforgiving on my body. Alas, I was not willing to give up. Was it so hard to find a pair that looked flawless with loafers but didn’t cost me a months rent to hem them? When looking for the best cropped denim, I discovered that there are a few key elements you need to asses.

1. Check For Good Sizing Options For Cropped Jeans

You want your cropped jeans to feature a range of size options. Besides just your average waist size, it’s great if they also come in petite, regular and longs for every height.

2. Look At The Closures On The Cropped Jeans

The best cropped jeans always have a high-waist with quality closures. You don’t want buttons or zippers breaking while you wear your new cropped denim in. Bonus points if they include a panel to slim your figure.

3. Test Out The Comfort Of The Cropped Jeans

Are the cropped jeans ACTUALLY comfortable? There’s nothing worse than a pair of jeans that you have to do 27 lunges in the morning to stretch out. Look for a pair that gives you wiggle room to treat yourself to that pizza on a Thursday night.

4. Check Out The Wash Of The Cropped Jeans

Do these jeans have a good wash? The last thing you want is to throw your jeans in the laundry only to have them come out three shades lighter than they were when you put them in. You also don’t want the dye to constantly rub off and give you black and blue hands.

After what seemed like months of agonizing shopping, I came across a high-waisted pair while perusing Nordstrom. I instantly took them to the dressing room to try on and to my surprise, I had to ask for a size down. Once I found the proper size I was in awe. They weren’t too long or too short. They were stretchy in a comfortable way but not in a way that loses the shape easily. The high waist silhouette and button closures allow for just enough wiggle room for those days you’re really bloated or ate too much pasta. In fact, they were just right. I don’t just consider them the best cropped jeans I own, I also file them under the best black jeans I own thanks to the gorgeous in-between black wash.

I wore them twice that week and couldn’t believe the number of compliments I received. I mean, people actually stopped me in the street to ask me where I got them! I felt like I held the key to the best hidden denim secret in New York. To add to my delight, I saw a paparazzi photo of Selena Gomez wearing the same exact jeans out in LA. If they’re good enough for Selena’s secret date with the Biebs, then that’s good enough for me.

I’m not the only one who loved them, customers gave these jeans rave reviews. Some customers loved these because they were some of the best cropped jeans for curvy women they’ve ever tried. Others thought they were the best cropped jeans for petite and tall ladies thanks to the inclusive sizing range.

One customer who recently had a baby said:

“These jeans make me look like a rock star. I’ve spent hundreds looking for the perfect jeans and happy to say the search is over. The tag on the jeans states: ‘We’ve reinforced the front pockets of our High Risers with a new construction that holds you in and creates a super-slimming effect (plus, a touch of added stretch ensures you’re still totally comfortable.’ Every. Word. Is. TRUE! But if you were to ask me how I’d describe these jeans in my own words? My reply: Unicorn Magic. The asymmetrical hem and high rise is the right-now look I’ll be wearing forever — with colorful flats, ankle boots, sneakers. I purchased the Woodston Wash but intend to purchase in these jeans in every flavor. For reference, I’m 5′ 3″ and postpartum typically take a size 31. For these jeans with the comfy stretch, I went with a size down. Couldn’t be happier!”

Another one raved:

“The reviews are right, these are 5 Stars!!! I just received them & they are a cool black/grey rinse, high rise is perfect & the exterior buttons are just an awesome look!!! SO worth the $$$ !! I sized down from 25 to 24 (5’5” 125 lb) & the fit is spot-on! These are a multi-season jean, you can wear any shoes with them— sooooo happy :))”

If those aren’t your particular style, here are four more pairs that have equally good reviews for every budget!

american eagle cropped denim

American Eagle High-Waisted Crop Flare Jean ($49.95)

everlane cropped denim

Everlane Women’s Kick Crop Jeans ($78)

mother cropped denim

MOTHER “The Insider” Crop Step Jeans ($205)

old navy cropped denim

Old Navy Eco-Friendly Boyfriend Straight Raw-Hem Jeans ($39.99)


More on SheFinds:

-The Super Affordable Jeans Celebrities Swear By For An Instant Butt Lift


-The Spring Trend You Should Be Wearing Right Now


-These Are The Best Running Sneakers, According To Bloggers

SheFinds receives commissions for purchases made through the links in this post.


Commerce Editor

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


The Unexpected Color Trend That Is About To Be Everywhere This Winter

The first day of Winter may technically not ...


Nordstrom Shoppers Love These Pants Because They're *So* Slimming

If you're planning to retire your skirts and dresses ...


12 Gift Ideas For Everyone On Your Holiday List

The holidays are right around the corner, and that means ...


You Can Stop Looking--These Are The Best Leather Tote Bags To Carry Laptops, Lipsticks And More

Finding a beautiful leather (or vegan leather) tote bag that'...