Skip to main content
Stylish haircuts for women over 50 trending in 2026.
Donald Trump discusses maternal healthcare at public event.
Queen Camilla and Kate Middleton at royal event.

Health

2 Surprising Supplements That Can Damage Your Heart Health, According To Experts

June 8, 2023 by Faith Geiger
shefinds | Health
Featured image

Supplements can be a great way to fill any nutrient gaps in your diet or target a range of health needs, from sleep to weight loss. However, it’s important to be aware of the risks that come with certain supplements. In fact, there are several options that come with potentially dangerous health effects. That includes a few products that could take a toll on your heart health if you don’t exercise caution.

To discover some supplement mistakes that might damage your heart health, we spoke to Robert Iafelice, MS, RDN. He told us that you should be careful not to take calcium without magnesium or fish oil without antioxidants. Learn more about the risks of these supplements below.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
calcium supplements

1. Calcium without magnesium

Taking a calcium supplement can be a great way to promote, strong, healthy bones in addition to eating vitamin D-rich foods. However, Iafelice says that ensuring you take calcium supplements that contain magnesium is crucial, as an imbalance of calcium and magnesium could result in cardiovascular issues.

"Calcium and magnesium need to be in balance," he says. "Many people take calcium supplements that do not contain magnesium, this can result in a relative deficiency of magnesium, especially if the person is also eating a lot of dairy foods." This deficiency can be detrimental to your health because, as he notes, in addition to being essential for things like sleep and weight loss, "magnesium is essential for keeping the heart pumping with a normal heart rhythm" and "a lack of magnesium can lead to arrhythmias or Afib."

For this reason, he says you should only take calcium if it's balanced with magnesium; a 1:1 ratio is ideal.

fish oil supplements in hand

2. Fish oil without preservatives (antioxidants)

Fish oil is another supplement that's known to boost heart health and help you shed pounds. While it may seem counterintuitive, though, Iafelice warns that "while fish oil is very beneficial for cardiovascular health, it can be harmful."

The issues arise when fish oil isn't preserved with antioxidants like vitamin C, E, or astanxanthin. When this happens, "fish oil is extremely susceptible to rancidity and the production of toxic byproducts." Yikes! This means it's important for fish oil supplements to be properly preserved.

"Always be sure that your fish oil has antioxidants in it to protect it from rancidity," he says.

woman browsing supplement aisle

The bottom line

Ultimately, supplements are supposed to help your health—not harm it. However, if you're not careful with the type of supplements you take and the way in which you take them, you could be setting yourself up for adverse effects, especially in the cardiovascular department. Luckily, if you follow Iafelice's advice by taking calcium with magnesium and ensuring your fish supplements are properly preserved with antioxidants, you should be in the clear to reap their benefits without putting your health at risk.

READ MORE: 6 Supplements You Should Be Taking Over 50 For A Longer Life

Author:

Freelance Writer

Faith Geiger is a New York-based writer and editor. When she's not covering the latest in health and wellness for SheFinds, she spends her time watching reality TV with her roommates, browsing used bookstores, and enjoying live music. You can reach Faith at faithkgeiger@gmail.com.

Healthy seeds versus pastries for nutritious snacking.
Grocery store aisle with sugar and artificial sweeteners.
Image from SHEfinds
Woman enjoying a calming cup of spearmint tea.
Frustrated older woman with blonde hair touching her head
Image from SHEfinds
Array of different bread types on display.
Woman holding her head in contemplation.
Woman experiencing discomfort from joint pain.
Popular fast food brands featuring donuts and coffee.
Woman adding sugar to a steaming cup of coffee.
Wooden board with bagels, blueberries, and butter.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for beauty benefits.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil for health.
Image from SHEfinds
Traditional Brazilian dish of rice, beans, and chicken.
Image from SHEfinds
Checking the time while enjoying a healthy breakfast.
Image from SHEfinds
Image from SHEfinds
Healthy seeds versus pastries for nutritious snacking.
Grocery store aisle with sugar and artificial sweeteners.
Image from SHEfinds
Woman enjoying a calming cup of spearmint tea.
Frustrated older woman with blonde hair touching her head
Image from SHEfinds
Array of different bread types on display.
Woman holding her head in contemplation.
Woman experiencing discomfort from joint pain.
Popular fast food brands featuring donuts and coffee.
Woman adding sugar to a steaming cup of coffee.
Wooden board with bagels, blueberries, and butter.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for beauty benefits.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil for health.
Image from SHEfinds
Traditional Brazilian dish of rice, beans, and chicken.
Image from SHEfinds
Checking the time while enjoying a healthy breakfast.
Image from SHEfinds
Image from SHEfinds