It’s no surprise that Stuart Weitzman Lowland Boot ($798) knockoffs are rampant. The “it” shoe is a favorite of Gigi Hadid, Lily Aldridge, and Karlie Kloss, after all. However, I have never come across such a good lookalike of, well, anything in my life. Sam Edelman‘s Paloma Boots ($175) have the same exact shape and design, down to the ties on the top of the shoes. I seriously have to keep double checking which boot is which as I’m writing this post. Can you tell which over-the-knee boots cost $623 more than the other? Click below to find out!