Skip to main content
Tired woman showing effects of lack of sleep.
Delicious banana nice cream dessert for healthy eating.
Jennifer Lopez stunning in Defaience at AMAs 2025.

Food

Health Coach Reveals The 'Best' And 'Worst' Nut Butters If You're Trying To Lose Weight

August 12, 2025 by Mariam Qayum
shefinds | Food
Featured image

When it comes to grocery shopping for nut butter, not all jars are created equal—especially if your goal is weight loss. Certified health coach Hunter recently took to Costco to share his go-to picks and the ones you should avoid at all costs.

“I’m at Costco, and I wanna show you the most unhealthy and healthiest nut butter to buy,” he begins.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
Image from SHEfinds

Worst Nut Butter: Skippy

Hunter admits he relied on Skippy for 20 years, but now it’s at the top of his “do not buy” list.

“They have the creamy and they have the chunky one behind me. This is the worst possible option here,” he says. “Skippy’s full of non-organic peanuts, sugar—which is all refined sugar—and hydrogenated vegetable oils, which is cottonseed, soybean, or rapeseed oil. Now, that is pretty alarming to me because that’s so unnecessary and it’s awful for our body, our skin, and our gut health.”

Image from SHEfinds

Best Nut Butter: Costco Kirkland Organic Peanut Butter

If you want the cleanest option, Hunter says Costco’s own brand nails it.

“I’m so thankful that Costco makes their own organic peanut butter made with just organic Valencia peanuts and salt. This is the perfect nut butter that you want to buy at Costco.”

Image from SHEfinds

Other Top Picks

Hunter’s healthy recommendations don’t stop at peanut butter.

“Costco also has two other organic nut butters that I’m obsessed with,” he explains. “They have this one by Nuttzo that uses superfoods and real ingredients. And they also have their own organic almond butter that’s made with just organic almonds.”

The bottom line

Skip the sugar- and oil-filled jars and choose nut butters with the shortest ingredient lists possible.

“Ditch the Skippy and the other junk nut butters and go for these to eat clean and feel good,” says Hunter.

Author:

Editorial Assistant

Mariam is an Editorial Assistant and writer at SheFinds, covering everything from style and beauty to health and wellness. Splitting her time between New York and Philadelphia, she brings a sharp eye for trends and a passion for storytelling to the digital space. With a strong editorial background, she’s always exploring the latest in fashion, skincare, and wellness. When she’s not writing or pitching, you’ll find her in the kitchen experimenting with new recipes or planning her next travel adventure. You can reach Mariam at mariam@shefinds.com.

Drinking spearmint tea for beauty benefits
Various types of bread displayed on a table.
Delicious pastries displayed at Costco bakery section.
Woman holding her head in distress or pain.
Woman suffering from joint pain while seated.
Woman experimenting with beauty trends for youthful skin
Popular fast food outlets: Dunkin', Chick-fil-A, Starbucks.
Woman adding sugar to her aromatic coffee.
Delicious bagels with blueberries and butter on a wooden board.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil for healthy cooking.
Brazilian dish with rice, beans, and chicken on a plate.
Checking the time while enjoying a balanced breakfast.
Display of deli meats and sandwich products at grocery store.
Cooked salmon served with rice, avocado, and greens.
Inside view of a Costco store showcasing products.
Woman taking magnesium supplement for health benefits.
Selection of s'mores brownies and baked ricotta from Aldi.
Grilled chicken breast with fries and mixed green salad.
Frozen pizza options displayed in grocery store aisle.
Fried fish served with crispy fries on a plate.
Drinking spearmint tea for beauty benefits
Various types of bread displayed on a table.
Delicious pastries displayed at Costco bakery section.
Woman holding her head in distress or pain.
Woman suffering from joint pain while seated.
Woman experimenting with beauty trends for youthful skin
Popular fast food outlets: Dunkin', Chick-fil-A, Starbucks.
Woman adding sugar to her aromatic coffee.
Delicious bagels with blueberries and butter on a wooden board.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil for healthy cooking.
Brazilian dish with rice, beans, and chicken on a plate.
Checking the time while enjoying a balanced breakfast.
Display of deli meats and sandwich products at grocery store.
Cooked salmon served with rice, avocado, and greens.
Inside view of a Costco store showcasing products.
Woman taking magnesium supplement for health benefits.
Selection of s'mores brownies and baked ricotta from Aldi.
Grilled chicken breast with fries and mixed green salad.
Frozen pizza options displayed in grocery store aisle.
Fried fish served with crispy fries on a plate.