Skip to main content
Kim Kardashian at Kering's Caring for Women Dinner
Madonna in blue mini dress at Paris event
Taylor Swift boarding private jet in 2024

Celebrity

Carrie Underwood Breaks Down In Tears On 'American Idol' As Contestant Who Lost Her Sister To Overdose Auditions: 'Absolute Trigger On Emotions'

April 4, 2025 by Julia DeKorte
shefinds | Celebrity
Featured image

We’re only a few episodes in to the 23rd season of America Idol and Carrie Underwood is already in tears over the contestants. Country singer Samantha Ray sang her own rendition of “I Hope You Dance” by Lee Ann Womack in honor of her late sister whom she used to harmonize with. The experience brought judge Carrie Underwood to tears—keep reading to learn more.

Carrie Underwood Gets Emotional

Just before beginning her song, Samantha Ray explained that she chose this song in particular because she and her sister used to harmonize to it. Then, when she finished her performance of the moving song, judge Luke Bryan asked her, “What were you thinking about when you sang that?”

“I was thinking about my sister a lot,” Samantha Ray explained. “Earlier this year in February, I lost her to a drug overdose. Losing her hurts a lot because she was a year younger than me; we were very close. She had two little boys, and knowing they don’t have their mom anymore is really heartbreaking. So I’m here for her.”

Underwood’s reaction was certainly emotional: “I’m teary-eyed,” she said, before complimenting the singer on her storytelling ability and telling her it’s an absolute “yes” from her.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
carrie underwood american idol

Fan Reactions

A clip of Samantha Ray's audition was posted to YouTube, and the comment section is filled with reactions like Carrie's. "She's a standout," one person wrote. "She has the 80s/90s country sound, and her rendition of that special song took me back to the days when my mom was still alive. And then I couldn't help but shed a few tears after hearing about her sister. I hope she goes far in this competition and beyond."

"May I never take on single breath for granted!" another person reacted.

"Samantha, I am so sorry for your devastating loss," another person wrote. "Carrie holding it together better than I am—blubbering mess over here!"

"Addition is brutal," a final person said. "It affects the entire family. my heart goes out to her."

Author:

Freelance Writer

Julia DeKorte is a New York-based writer. A graduate of the Columbia Publishing Course, Julia covers celebrity and brand news for SheFinds, reviews toys and games for People of Play, and loves cooking for her family, walking her dogs, and running outside, preferably in view of the ocean.

Emma Stone at Annual Actor Awards, celebrating cinematic achievements.
Salma Hayek at 12th Annual Breakthrough Prize Ceremony, glamorous look.
Ariana Grande at Golden Globes, stunning red carpet appearance.
Kylie Jenner in tailored black outfit at Met Gala 2025.
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce sharing a moment together.
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner at public engagement.
Bad Bunny performing at the Grammy Awards, energetic scene.
Angelina Jolie receiving The Trophee Chopard Award, elegant attire.
Selena Gomez at 3rd Annual Rare Impact Fund Benefit, impactful charity.
Brad Pitt and Ines de Ramon at F1 World Premiere event.
Queen Camilla with Prince Harry and Meghan Markle at event.
Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift enjoying a date together.
Barack and Michelle Obama with Malia and Sasha at event.
Britney Spears at 4th Annual Hollywood Beauty Awards, glamorous moment.
Savannah Guthrie hosting Today Show, engaging with audience.
Beyoncé and Jay-Z at event, showcasing their iconic style.
Reese Witherspoon at Apple TV's The Last Thing He Told Me premiere.
Meghan Markle with Prince Harry and Prince William at an event.
Hillary Clinton at the Suffs Broadway Opening Night event.
Hailey Bieber attending the Women's Wear Daily Style Awards.
Emma Stone at Annual Actor Awards, celebrating cinematic achievements.
Salma Hayek at 12th Annual Breakthrough Prize Ceremony, glamorous look.
Ariana Grande at Golden Globes, stunning red carpet appearance.
Kylie Jenner in tailored black outfit at Met Gala 2025.
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce sharing a moment together.
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner at public engagement.
Bad Bunny performing at the Grammy Awards, energetic scene.
Angelina Jolie receiving The Trophee Chopard Award, elegant attire.
Selena Gomez at 3rd Annual Rare Impact Fund Benefit, impactful charity.
Brad Pitt and Ines de Ramon at F1 World Premiere event.
Queen Camilla with Prince Harry and Meghan Markle at event.
Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift enjoying a date together.
Barack and Michelle Obama with Malia and Sasha at event.
Britney Spears at 4th Annual Hollywood Beauty Awards, glamorous moment.
Savannah Guthrie hosting Today Show, engaging with audience.
Beyoncé and Jay-Z at event, showcasing their iconic style.
Reese Witherspoon at Apple TV's The Last Thing He Told Me premiere.
Meghan Markle with Prince Harry and Prince William at an event.
Hillary Clinton at the Suffs Broadway Opening Night event.
Hailey Bieber attending the Women's Wear Daily Style Awards.