Skip to main content
Nicole Kidman at Kering Women in Motion event in gray blazer.
Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively at a celebrity event
Michelle Obama at the 2024 Albies ceremony

Food

The Costco Seasonal Dessert Customers Say You Should Never Buy: '1/10' And 'Hated It'

November 1, 2023 by Julia DeKorte
shefinds | Food
Featured image

Costco is a pretty universally loved retail wholesale store, with quality items at great prices, from grocery items to furniture, and appliances to clothing. However, one of Costco’s newest bakery items has missed the mark, according to customer reviews. Shoppers are calling the Caramel Apple Mini Cakes “not good at all” and “very dry” with a “terrible artificial caramel taste.”

This just goes to show that not every item can be a winner—even at Costco. Luckily, there are a plethora of accounts on Instagram dedicated to reviewing the newest Costco items so you can know which are better left on the shelf, including these Caramel Apple Mini Cakes. Find more of what Costco shoppers have to say about this seasonal dessert.

below.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Costco Food Reviews (@costcofoodreviews)

Costco misses the mark with ‘Caramel Apple Mini Cakes’

With ‘caramel apple’ being one of the most popular flavors of the fall, shoppers had high hopes for the new seasonal dessert. However, many were ultimately disappointed. The mini cakes cost $8.99 and come in a package of six—which seems like a great deal. Unfortunately, though, while they’re found in the beloved bakery section among many fan-favorite items like the Mini Carrot Cakes with Cream Cheese Frosting and Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream Pie, this item misses the mark.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
costco bakery

Instagram users weigh in on the 'disappointing' seasonal dessert

The Instagram account @CostcoFoodReviews posted a carousel of photos of the Caramel Apple Mini Cakes on Oct. 8th, with a lengthy review in the caption. "These were not my favorite mini cakes that I’ve tried from Costco," the review began. "The baked cinnamon apples on top were very tasty," the user continued, "but the overall artificial caramel flavor overpowered this dessert for me."

 

Though the account owner gave the dessert a 5/10, their 54.7K followers weren’t as nice. "1/10 I hated them," one follower commented. "I was so disappointed," another replied, adding a frowny face.

 

"Me and all my staff hated these," one user said. "The frosting on ours was like a stick of butter," they added. "I thought these were a huge miss!!" another shopper added with a barfing emoji.

 

One reddit user posted that the mini cakes "tasted like how a campfire smells." We're not sure what that means, but don’t want to find out!

 

Safe to say we will be taking these users' word for it and steering clear of this fall dessert! For Costco items that are always a winner with customers, check out these fan-favorite items.

Author:

Freelance Writer

Julia DeKorte is a New York-based writer. A graduate of the Columbia Publishing Course, Julia covers celebrity and brand news for SheFinds, reviews toys and games for People of Play, and loves cooking for her family, walking her dogs, and running outside, preferably in view of the ocean.

Michelle Obama at a public event
Popular coffee shop logos on display
Woman adding sugar to steaming coffee
Bagels with blueberries and butter on wooden board
Cooking spray versus olive oil comparison
Traditional Brazilian dish with rice, beans, and chicken
Checking watch while enjoying breakfast
Display of deli meats and sandwiches in grocery store
Cooked salmon served with rice and greens
Inside view of a Costco store
Woman taking magnesium supplement
Selection of s'mores brownies from bakery
Grilled chicken breast with fries and salad
Frozen pizza available in grocery store
Fried fish served with fries
Spilling vitamin C pills into hand
Purple sweet potato with hands on stomach
Moringa powder and fresh leaves on display
Woman using fabric softener during laundry at home.
Fit woman enjoying a healthy meal with avocados and vegetables.
Michelle Obama at a public event
Popular coffee shop logos on display
Woman adding sugar to steaming coffee
Bagels with blueberries and butter on wooden board
Cooking spray versus olive oil comparison
Traditional Brazilian dish with rice, beans, and chicken
Checking watch while enjoying breakfast
Display of deli meats and sandwiches in grocery store
Cooked salmon served with rice and greens
Inside view of a Costco store
Woman taking magnesium supplement
Selection of s'mores brownies from bakery
Grilled chicken breast with fries and salad
Frozen pizza available in grocery store
Fried fish served with fries
Spilling vitamin C pills into hand
Purple sweet potato with hands on stomach
Moringa powder and fresh leaves on display
Woman using fabric softener during laundry at home.
Fit woman enjoying a healthy meal with avocados and vegetables.