Skip to main content

Celebrity

Fans Compare Mariah Carey To Mitch McConnell After Her 'Stiff' And 'Lifeless' Viral Performance: 'Something Is Clearly Off'

November 22, 2026 by Maria Pierides
shefinds | Celebrity
Featured image

Mariah Carey sparked concern from fans after videos from the opening night of her Christmas Time tour in Brazil went viral, with some even comparing her to Mitch McConnell over her “stiff” movements on stage.

The undisputed Queen of Christmas, 57, kicked off her festive tour at Nubank Parque in São Paulo, Brazil, on Tuesday, November 17th. However, fans were distracted by how much assistance she appeared to need from her backup dancers, who were seen guiding her around the stage and even helping her lift her leg during the choreography.

And with reports suggesting she may need hip replacement surgery next year, fans are wondering whether her health could be behind her unusual movements. Keep reading for more info…

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Philipe Watfe (@philipewatfe)

Mariah Carey’s ‘Stiff’ Movements During Christmas Tour Performance Spark Concern

In one viral video, the Grammy winner looked glamorous in a dazzling champagne-colored dress, with her long hair styled in voluminous curls. But it was her movements, rather than her outfit, that got people talking.

At one point, her dancers could be seen holding her hands as she walked down some steps. And when she attempted to dip backward and extend her leg, one dancer appeared to lift her leg while the others supported her upper body.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Leandro Sanuty (@lehsanutyoficial)

The performance came just days after Carey was spotted holding onto an assistant’s arm and seemingly wobbling while signing autographs for fans outside her São Paulo hotel. She was also wearing flat Gucci loafers instead of her signature towering heels. And you know it’s unusual when Mariah, who has even worn heels to Disneyland, is spotted in flats!

This isn’t the first time fans have questioned her movements, either. Earlier this year, fans noticed her hands shaking during a performance at Tiffany & Co.’s Blue Book 2026: Hidden Garden launch event in New York City.

And last year, some even speculated that she had been replaced by a doppelgänger or robot, while another interview that year had them wondering whether AI was used for her part of the interview, as they didn’t think she was real!

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
Mariah Carey performing Christmas tour

Mariah Carey Reportedly Facing Hip Replacement Surgery After Christmas

The speculation comes amid a report from Rob Shuter's Naughty But Nice Substack, which claims the "Touch My Body" singer is expected to undergo urgent hip replacement surgery next year. Despite the urgency, sources claim she is determined to complete her Christmas commitments first.

If the reports are true, her alleged hip problems could explain some of her recent difficulties moving around. Fans have also speculated that she may be taking strong pain medication to get through her shows, although there is no confirmation that she is taking any such medication.

"Mariah has been having real problems getting around. She's been using a scooter privately, and hip replacement surgery is expected next year," a source told Naughty But Nice in an article published two days before her first show. "But she's determined to get through Christmas first. Nothing is going to stop her holiday season," they added.

Another insider told Shuter: "She knows people are talking about the videos, but she doesn't want anyone feeling sorry for her. Mariah is a fighter. She wants to finish her Christmas commitments, enjoy the holidays and deal with the surgery afterward."

Mariah Carey performing Christmas tour

Fans Express Concern Over Mariah Carey's 'Stiff' Performance On Social Media

Fans wasted no time commenting on Carey's performance. "Is Mariah Carey choosing to perform as stiff as possible, or is something going on with her health?" wrote one X user. "Is something wrong with her? Why does she need help to walk off the stage?" asked a second, as a third commented: "Something's wrong I saw another video she can barely walk."

"This is sad, I love Mariah, she looks like she is in a lot of pain or maybe dizzy or her balance is off or something, like from vertigo maybe?" speculated a fourth. "There's obviously something wrong. People shouldn't be making fun of her," insisted a fifth, while a sixth simply wrote: "Heavily medicated."

 
 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Leandro Sanuty (@lehsanutyoficial)

Over on Instagram, reactions ranged from jokes about the "Vision of Love" singer's choreography to genuine concern about her health. Some even drew comparisons to Céline Dion, who has publicly spoken about her battle with Stiff Person Syndrome.

"I have never seen someone doing the absolute most and the absolute least at the same time," joked one Instagram user. "The bending of the leg is sending me," wrote a second. "It's giving Mitch McConnell," commented a third, referencing the Kentucky U.S. senator's concerning behavior in recent years.

"She's giving Wendy," added a fourth, seemingly referencing Wendy Williams, whose own health struggles have sparked widespread concern from fans in recent years. "Is this dancing I'm not sure what it is," questioned a fifth, while a sixth simply wrote: "Cringe." "All jokes aside... Is she ok?" asked a seventh.

"Something's been off for a while now," agreed an eighth. "I'm truly concerned," added a ninth. "She looks spaced out," observed a tenth, while an eleventh commented: "She look weird up there." A twelfth said she seemed "lifeless" on stage, while a thirteenth joked: "If 'handle with care' was a person."

Others pointed to the reports about her rumored hip replacement surgery, with a fourteenth fan writing: "Yall she's reportedly looking at hip replacement surgery. Poor thing's probably on heavy pain meds at 57, can't be easy." "She's fighting through the pain," added a fifteenth.

However, not everyone shared the same concerns, with several fans who attended the concert defending the singer and insisting that she put on an incredible show...

"I was there and didn't have a single concern. It was all euphoria and joy to see her on stage," wrote one fan in her defense. "The show was perfect!" praised a second, followed by three clapping emojis. "Stop spreading hate. The concert was amazing! Brazil loves Mariah," exclaimed a third.

Author:

Senior Celebrity Writer

Maria has spent the last decade writing about entertainment, fashion, and lifestyle for online and print publications all around the globe – including InStyle, OK!, and The Mirror. At SheFinds, Maria covers breaking celebrity news, red carpet looks, celebrity transformations, A-list couples, and has a watchful eye on celebrity social media accounts. You can reach her at maria@shefinds.com