Skip to main content
Tired woman showing effects of lack of sleep.
Delicious banana nice cream dessert for healthy eating.
Jennifer Lopez stunning in Defaience at AMAs 2025.

Food

The One Thing You Should Never Order At Five Guys, According To An Employee

October 26, 2018 by Justine Schwartz
shefinds | Food
Featured image

Five Guys has been named America’s number one burger chain in the past, but just like any fast food chain, it stumbles sometimes.

If you’re a loyal fan of the greasy burgers and peanuts, then you might not want to keep reading. We’ve scoured the underbelly of the web, aka Reddit “Ask Me Anything” threads to find out the brutal truth about Five Guys food and service. Want to know the one thing you shouldn’t order at the popular chain? Keep reading, brave souls (and strong stomachs):

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
Juicy gourmet burger with fresh toppings and melted cheese

The meat is questionable, according to a former employee. Yikes! He/she/they write that the meat, "Was unsafe to serve to guests," the user says. But wait--it gets worse: "Gray, slimy meat that we were still forced to serve. Also, meat that fell on the floor." Say it ain't so!

Deliciously stacked burger with crispy bacon and vegetables

Additionally, there's a reason that their patties are so juicy--they don't press the fat out! The Reddist user revealed the questionable cooking method, "We're not supposed to press down on it, that removes the juices," they said." Sorry, heart!

Crispy golden French fries served in a rustic bowl

Also, it turns out that extra scoop policy is a bit of a rip-off. One employee writes, "When you order a small fry (for example, but they do this for all sizes) you are paying for all of the fries that go into the bag. That 'extra' scoop is kind of an illusion, they told us during training that its to make customers think they're getting a big bargain."

 

So, what do you think? Will you still be eating Five Guys after reading this? Let us know in the comments below!

Author:

Editorial Director

Justine Schwartz is a veteran women's lifestyle editor; she's written extensively about style & beauty tips, health advice and wedding planning. Her work has appeared in New York Magazine, Huffington Post and New York Weddings. Justine has been with SheFinds since 2010; you can reach her via email at Justine@shefinds.com.

Drinking spearmint tea for beauty benefits
Various types of bread displayed on a table.
Delicious pastries displayed at Costco bakery section.
Woman holding her head in distress or pain.
Woman suffering from joint pain while seated.
Woman experimenting with beauty trends for youthful skin
Popular fast food outlets: Dunkin', Chick-fil-A, Starbucks.
Woman adding sugar to her aromatic coffee.
Delicious bagels with blueberries and butter on a wooden board.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil for healthy cooking.
Brazilian dish with rice, beans, and chicken on a plate.
Checking the time while enjoying a balanced breakfast.
Display of deli meats and sandwich products at grocery store.
Cooked salmon served with rice, avocado, and greens.
Inside view of a Costco store showcasing products.
Woman taking magnesium supplement for health benefits.
Selection of s'mores brownies and baked ricotta from Aldi.
Grilled chicken breast with fries and mixed green salad.
Frozen pizza options displayed in grocery store aisle.
Fried fish served with crispy fries on a plate.
Drinking spearmint tea for beauty benefits
Various types of bread displayed on a table.
Delicious pastries displayed at Costco bakery section.
Woman holding her head in distress or pain.
Woman suffering from joint pain while seated.
Woman experimenting with beauty trends for youthful skin
Popular fast food outlets: Dunkin', Chick-fil-A, Starbucks.
Woman adding sugar to her aromatic coffee.
Delicious bagels with blueberries and butter on a wooden board.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil for healthy cooking.
Brazilian dish with rice, beans, and chicken on a plate.
Checking the time while enjoying a balanced breakfast.
Display of deli meats and sandwich products at grocery store.
Cooked salmon served with rice, avocado, and greens.
Inside view of a Costco store showcasing products.
Woman taking magnesium supplement for health benefits.
Selection of s'mores brownies and baked ricotta from Aldi.
Grilled chicken breast with fries and mixed green salad.
Frozen pizza options displayed in grocery store aisle.
Fried fish served with crispy fries on a plate.