Skip to main content

Food

Starbucks Customers Say Digital Tipping Creates An 'Awkward Situation' At Checkout: 'Tipping Culture Is Toxic'

November 16, 2026 by Mariam Qayum
shefinds | Food
Featured image

Tipping culture has become a hot-button issue at businesses across the country, and Starbucks is the latest chain facing complaints about how it asks customers to leave gratuities. A viral Reddit discussion has sparked debate about the coffee giant’s digital tipping experience, with some customers saying the checkout process has become uncomfortable for both them and baristas.

In a Reddit post titled “What have they done to tipping???”, one Starbucks customer claimed the company had removed the option to leave a tip through the app when placing an order in person. They also suggested that some baristas were skipping the tipping prompt on the payment terminal, leaving customers who wanted to show their appreciation unsure of how to do so.

“They managed to create an awkward situation where they removed tipping from the app when you order in store but baristas seem like they don’t want to put the customer in a position to press an option on the screen so they just void the tip. So now I have to preface that I want to tip as I’m ordering so they don’t. Why can’t they just bring back tipping in the app??” the customer wrote.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!

Starbucks' Tipping Experience Divides Customers

However, Starbucks' tipping options are more complicated than the post suggests, and the company has not eliminated digital tipping across the board.

In April 2026, Starbucks announced an expansion of its digital tipping options, allowing customers to leave gratuities by credit or debit card through Mobile Order & Pay and when using the Starbucks app's Scan & Pay feature at the register. The rollout began in July at company-operated U.S. locations.

The distinction is important: Mobile Order & Pay allows customers to place and pay for an order through the app before picking it up, while Scan & Pay lets customers pay through the app at the register when ordering in person. These are separate transactions, and the tipping options may differ depending on how the customer pays.

In the Reddit discussion, one commenter pointed out that customers who place mobile orders can still add a tip after purchasing by opening the receipt in the app. The original poster clarified that this option was not appearing for orders placed in person.

In other words, the customer's complaint appears to concern the tipping experience for in-store orders rather than the complete removal of app-based tipping. The post also raises a separate issue: whether baristas are choosing to bypass the tip prompt on the payment screen to avoid putting customers on the spot.

Several commenters who identified themselves as Starbucks workers shared how they try to make the interaction less uncomfortable.

"Tips stopped being awkward for me when I started being direct about it. Both in the DT and paying with Starbucks card, if someone doesn’t notice it I say 'I’ll just need you to skip the tip screen for me.' If someone genuinely does want to tip it draws their attention to it so they know. If they don’t want to, saying 'skip the tip screen' instead of 'select an option' or something more evasive makes it really clear that tipping is not an expectation," one person explained.

They added that some customers have responded by saying, "Oh that's so kind to say but of course I'm not going to just SKIP it."

Another commenter questioned why customers are asked to tip before receiving their orders, writing, "It’s so dumb. I never understood pre-tipping at the register. A tip before service is rendered is called a bribe. I carry small bills for this reason."

Meanwhile, another Starbucks worker shared a different approach to making customers feel less pressured.

"I just say 'It’s gonna ask you a quick question but there are no wrong answers!' And give them a smile. It gets people to finish the transaction and takes the pressure off of tipping," they wrote.

Others suggested bringing back traditional tip jars to avoid digital prompts altogether. Not everyone was in favor of the tipping system, however. One former Starbucks employee said they never liked the expectation of tipping while working at the chain and had no plans to leave gratuities as a customer.

"I didn’t like the expectation of tipping when I was a partner. I won’t tip now. $1 on a $5 drink is a wild ask. Tipping culture is toxic," they wrote.

Although Starbucks has expanded the ways customers can leave tips, gratuities remain optional. Customers are not required to select a tip amount when completing a transaction, and the company does not make tipping mandatory.

Still, the Reddit discussion highlights a growing frustration with digital tipping prompts. While some customers appreciate having the option to reward baristas, others say being asked to make that decision during checkout creates unnecessary pressure—and even employees appear divided over how to handle the interaction.

Author:

Editorial Assistant

Mariam is an Editorial Assistant and writer at SheFinds, covering everything from style and beauty to health and wellness. Splitting her time between New York and Philadelphia, she brings a sharp eye for trends and a passion for storytelling to the digital space. With a strong editorial background, she’s always exploring the latest in fashion, skincare, and wellness. When she’s not writing or pitching, you’ll find her in the kitchen experimenting with new recipes or planning her next travel adventure. You can reach Mariam at mariam@shefinds.com.