Skip to main content
Tired woman showing effects of lack of sleep on her face.
Creamy banana nice cream in a bowl with toppings.
Jennifer Lopez at 2025 American Music Awards in stylish outfit.

Health

These 6 Common Supplements May Have More Downsides Than Benefits, According To Experts: Kava, More

May 11, 2026 by Faith Geiger
shefinds | Health
Featured image

Supplements can be a great way to keep your health in the best possible shape. They can fill nutrient gaps left in your diet, improve sleep, and even lower stress levels. However, not all supplements are created equal. While many follow through on their promised benefits, a lot of supplements fall flat—and some can even come with dangerous side effects and downsides that negate the potential benefits altogether.

We spoke to Kristen Kuminski, RD, CDN, to shed some light on a few of the worst options on the market. According to her, supplements like kava, colloidal silver, and more should be avoided for your health and safety. Find all of her warnings below.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
Kava plant extract for relaxation and stress relief.

1. Kava

Some people reach for kava in times of stress and anxiety. It's commonly sold for its anti-anxiety benefits. However, Kuminski warns that the downsides may outweigh the momentary relaxation.

"Kava is marketed for anxiety relief but the hepatotoxicity risk is real and documented," she tells us. "Liver damage has been reported even with short term use at recommended doses." Instead, for a safer option, she recommends chamomile tea or magnesium glycinate, which provide anxiety support without the health risks.

Vitamin E oil for skin nourishment and hydration.

2. High dose vitamin E

Vitamin E is an antioxidant that supports immune function, skin health, and more. However, when you overdo it in the supplement department, you set your body up for health risks.

"Vitamin E supplementation above 400 IU daily is associated with increased mortality in several large studies and can interfere with blood clotting," Kuminski says. "Getting vitamin E through food, nuts, seeds, olive oil, is the better path." Noted!

Aristolochia indica plant known for its medicinal properties.

3. Aristolochic acid

Check the ingredients on your herbal supplements! Kuminski says there's one particular acid you should avoid. "Aristolochic acid shows up in some traditional herbal blends and is a known nephrotoxin and carcinogen," she says.

But even beyond the ingredient list, you might be unknowingly consuming this carcinogen. "The problem is it's not always labeled clearly. Avoiding unregulated herbal blends entirely is the safest move." Got it!

Colloidal silver solution for natural healing and antibacterial effects.

5. Colloidal silver

Supplemental colloidal silver makes a lot of promises: boosting immunity, fighting infection, combatting inflammation, and more. But remember, if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. According to Kuminski, such is the case with this "miracle worker."

"Colloidal silver has no proven benefit and causes argyria, permanent bluish gray skin discoloration, along with potential kidney damage and interference with antibiotic absorption," she says. "It has been aggressively marketed for decades without evidence." Stay away!

Beta carotene-rich foods promoting healthy skin and vision.

6. High dose beta carotene

Finally, if you smoke, Kuminski recommends staying away from high doses of one supplement in particular: beta carotene.

"High dose beta carotene supplements in smokers are associated with increased lung cancer risk based on two large clinical trials that were stopped early because of harm," she tells us. "Smokers should get carotenoids from whole vegetables only. Food sources carry none of the same risk."

All in all, it's important to be mindful of what you're putting into your body—including the supplements you take.

Author:

Freelance Writer

Faith Geiger is a New York-based writer and editor. When she's not covering the latest in health and wellness for SheFinds, she spends her time watching reality TV with her roommates, browsing used bookstores, and enjoying live music. You can reach Faith at faithkgeiger@gmail.com.

Healthy seeds displayed, contrasting with unhealthy pastries.
Grocery store aisle featuring sugar and artificial sweeteners.
Person enjoying a healthy lunch at a dining table.
Close-up of steaming spearmint tea with fresh leaves
Frustrated older woman holding her head in distress.
Woman experiencing chest pain, highlighting health concerns.
Variety of different types of bread on a table.
Woman holding her head in distress or pain.
Woman experiencing joint pain while sitting down.
Assorted drinks from Dunkin', Chick-fil-A, and Starbucks.
Woman adding sugar to a cup of aromatic coffee.
Wooden board with bagels, blueberries, and butter.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for health benefits.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil in a kitchen.
Older woman taking supplements with water for wellness.
Brazilian dish featuring rice, beans, and chicken.
Handful of dietary supplements for optimal nutrition.
Person checking the time while enjoying breakfast.
Close-up of supplement powder being poured into a glass.
Woman exercising outdoors for fitness.
Healthy seeds displayed, contrasting with unhealthy pastries.
Grocery store aisle featuring sugar and artificial sweeteners.
Person enjoying a healthy lunch at a dining table.
Close-up of steaming spearmint tea with fresh leaves
Frustrated older woman holding her head in distress.
Woman experiencing chest pain, highlighting health concerns.
Variety of different types of bread on a table.
Woman holding her head in distress or pain.
Woman experiencing joint pain while sitting down.
Assorted drinks from Dunkin', Chick-fil-A, and Starbucks.
Woman adding sugar to a cup of aromatic coffee.
Wooden board with bagels, blueberries, and butter.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for health benefits.
Comparing cooking spray and olive oil in a kitchen.
Older woman taking supplements with water for wellness.
Brazilian dish featuring rice, beans, and chicken.
Handful of dietary supplements for optimal nutrition.
Person checking the time while enjoying breakfast.
Close-up of supplement powder being poured into a glass.
Woman exercising outdoors for fitness.