Skip to main content
Jennifer Aniston gives Benny Blanco a stylish hair makeover.
Top summer scents of 2026 recommended by beauty editors.
Julia Roberts shines at the Critics' Choice Awards.

Celebrity

Fans Call Blake Lively 'Vindictive' And 'Manipulative' And Demand A 'Public Apology' To Justin Baldoni After She Drops Charges Against Him In Court

June 7, 2025 by Julia DeKorte
shefinds | Celebrity
Featured image

Blake Lively is now officially backtracking…or at least she’s trying to. The latest in the Lively-Baldoni lawsuit? The actress’ lawyers are attempting to withdraw her claims of emotional distress after Baldoni’s lawyers requested her mental health medical records. Keep reading for more information.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
blake lively justin baldoni

Blake Lively's Lawyers Attempt To Withdraw Emotional Distress Claims

In December 2024, Lively accused Baldoni of "severe emotional distress and pain, humiliation, embarrassment." Naturally, Baldoni's team asked her to release her medical records. Instead, Lively's team said they would withdraw those very claims.

In a letter to Judge Lewis. J. Liman, with an email exchange between the two teams attached, Baldoni's attorney Kevin Fitz of Meister Seelig & Fein said, "Ms. Lively's counsel recently advised us, in writing, that Ms. Lively is withdrawing her IED Claims." In this context, IED Claims refer to Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress.

Blake Lively

But, There's a But...

A cause for celebration in camp Baldoni, right? Wrong. Lively said she would drop the IED Claims without prejudice, which means the claim could be withdrawn now but could brought up again in the future.

Lively "can't have it both ways," Fitz said. "If Ms. Lively wants to withdraw her frivolous IED Claims, the Wayfarer Parties [Wayfarer Studios is Baldoni's production company] are entitled to a dismissal with prejudice to ensure they will not be re-filed. If Ms. Lively is unwilling to stipulate to the dismissal of her IED Claims with prejudice, then the Wayfarer Parties will continue to defend against them, and she must produce her medical information and documents as set forth herein."

Basically, Baldoni's lawyers want the claims gone for good, or else Lively must produce her medical records.

blake lively

Social Media Reactions

This news has made its way across social media, with fans of Justin Baldoni seeing this as a won battle. "We want a public apology for Baldoni and his family," one person wrote in a comment on Instagram.

"The most manipulative, vindictive human I've ever heard of," another added.

"She was clearly lying!" said a third.

"It's all crumbling down for Blake Lively," another user wrote. "Justice for Justin Baldoni!"

"Charge her for lying!" a final fan said. "Make an example. Trying to destroy someone's whole life shouldn't go unpunished!"

Author:

Freelance Writer

Julia DeKorte is a New York-based writer. A graduate of the Columbia Publishing Course, Julia covers celebrity and brand news for SheFinds, reviews toys and games for People of Play, and loves cooking for her family, walking her dogs, and running outside, preferably in view of the ocean.

Gwyneth Paltrow at the Golden Globes red carpet event.
Donald Trump and Melania Trump at a public appearance.
Angelina Jolie attending the AFI Fest 2023 event.
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce enjoying a night out together.
Ivanka Trump at the Fontainebleau Las Vegas Grand Opening.
Barron Trump during Donald Trump's inauguration ceremony.
Ariana Grande at the Oscars, showcasing her glamorous look.
Meghan Markle at Day 4 of the Invictus Games event.
Gigi Hadid arriving at the Le Grand Diner du Louvre.
Nate Bargatze at the 15th Annual Stand Up For Heroes benefit.
Taylor Swift at the Grammy Awards, celebrating her wins.
Jelly Roll and Bunnie XO at the Pre-Grammy Gala event.
Donald Trump and Barack Obama together at a public event.
Machine Gun Kelly performing at the BET Awards ceremony.
Catherine, Princess of Wales, at a wreath-laying service.
Harper Beckman at Netflix's 'Victoria Beckham' world premiere.
Shania Twain at Universal Music Group's Grammy Awards after-party.
Kim Kardashian attending the TIME100 Gala event.
Ivanka Trump with Tiffany, Kai, and Bettina Trump at an event.
Donald Trump at UFC Freedom 250 ring event.
Gwyneth Paltrow at the Golden Globes red carpet event.
Donald Trump and Melania Trump at a public appearance.
Angelina Jolie attending the AFI Fest 2023 event.
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce enjoying a night out together.
Ivanka Trump at the Fontainebleau Las Vegas Grand Opening.
Barron Trump during Donald Trump's inauguration ceremony.
Ariana Grande at the Oscars, showcasing her glamorous look.
Meghan Markle at Day 4 of the Invictus Games event.
Gigi Hadid arriving at the Le Grand Diner du Louvre.
Nate Bargatze at the 15th Annual Stand Up For Heroes benefit.
Taylor Swift at the Grammy Awards, celebrating her wins.
Jelly Roll and Bunnie XO at the Pre-Grammy Gala event.
Donald Trump and Barack Obama together at a public event.
Machine Gun Kelly performing at the BET Awards ceremony.
Catherine, Princess of Wales, at a wreath-laying service.
Harper Beckman at Netflix's 'Victoria Beckham' world premiere.
Shania Twain at Universal Music Group's Grammy Awards after-party.
Kim Kardashian attending the TIME100 Gala event.
Ivanka Trump with Tiffany, Kai, and Bettina Trump at an event.
Donald Trump at UFC Freedom 250 ring event.