Skip to main content
Tired woman showing effects of lack of sleep on her face.
Creamy banana nice cream in a bowl with toppings.
Jennifer Lopez at 2025 American Music Awards in stylish outfit.

Beauty

The Surprising Chapstick That Actually Makes Dry Lips Worse, According To Dermatologists

November 16, 2020 by Robyn Turk
shefinds | Beauty
Featured image

We all know that chapstick is a necessity in the winter time. As the air gets cool and dry, our lips seem to chap and crack more easily. Finding the right chapstick is essential to keeping your lips looking and feeling your best. But the right chapstick may not be as easy to find as we might think.

According to dermatologist Erum Ilyas, MD, MBE, FAAD, one of the most popular chapstick ingredients is actually one of the worst for your lips.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
menthol worst chapstick ingredient dry lips

Menthol is the worst ingredient you can use in chapstick. Most popular chapsticks are made with menthol, because people tend to like the refreshing, minty feeling.

But in reality, it doesn’t actually aid in healing or preventing chapped lips, and might even lead to irritation. In fact, using chapstick made with menthol might even cause your lips to dry out.

menthol worst chapstick ingredient dry lips

“Menthol gives a cooling sensation when applied and gives people the impression that their product is getting to work,” Dr. Ilyas told SheFinds. “This sensation is more of a marketing effect and less reflects an actual effect of the product. Patients often get ‘addicted’ to need this sensation to ‘feel’ like their product is working or do not think a product is effective if they do not feel the tingle! Menthol has been shown to contribute to some drying or irritation with long term use.”

menthol worst chapstick ingredient dry lips

Swap out your minty, menthol chapstick for something more hydrating - before the weather gets colder. Dr. Ilyas confirmed that our lips dry out more easily in the winter.

She explained, “As the weather gets cooler and drier, the thin skin of the lips tends to dry out faster than the rest of our skin. The lips can look dry, cracked, peeling and raw in some areas. It can be really sore and uncomfortable.”

menthol worst chapstick ingredient dry lips

The only way to heal and protect chapped lips is to rehydrate the skin with ingredients that create a barrier to seal in moisture.

Dr. Ilyas suggests using petroleum jelly or moisturizing ingredients like almond oil or vitamin E. Next time you shop for lip balm, pay close attention to the ingredient list to make sure you pick the most hydrating option.

Author:

Robyn Turk is a style and beauty writer, contributing to the SheFinds team. Her work has appeared in StyleCaster, Business Insider, Refinery29, DailyMail and others.

Viral Italian bob hairstyle trend for summer 2023.
Woman applying concealer for flawless makeup look.
Beauty habits causing skin inflammation explained.
Older woman enjoying skincare routine for healthy skin.
Close-up of steaming spearmint tea with fresh leaves
Common hair mistakes that may age you, according to stylists.
Anti-aging skincare tips with Arielle Lorre and Dr. Anthony Youn.
Best foundation types for mature skin to conceal fine lines.
Trendy butterfly haircut showcased on Instagram.
Fresh haircuts women are choosing for a polished look in 2026.
Pouring shampoo into hand for hair care routine.
Everyday habits that accelerate collagen breakdown revealed.
Celebrity event with fans capturing moments with phones.
Best summer scents and fragrances of 2026, according to beauty editors.
Makeup tips from beauty expert Nikol Johnson on YouTube.
Common skincare mistakes women over 40 make regarding fine lines.
Haircuts that divert attention from jowls and lift the face.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for health benefits.
Hailey Bieber's haircuts that add thickness to fine hair.
Stylish chiffon nails showcased on Instagram.
Viral Italian bob hairstyle trend for summer 2023.
Woman applying concealer for flawless makeup look.
Beauty habits causing skin inflammation explained.
Older woman enjoying skincare routine for healthy skin.
Close-up of steaming spearmint tea with fresh leaves
Common hair mistakes that may age you, according to stylists.
Anti-aging skincare tips with Arielle Lorre and Dr. Anthony Youn.
Best foundation types for mature skin to conceal fine lines.
Trendy butterfly haircut showcased on Instagram.
Fresh haircuts women are choosing for a polished look in 2026.
Pouring shampoo into hand for hair care routine.
Everyday habits that accelerate collagen breakdown revealed.
Celebrity event with fans capturing moments with phones.
Best summer scents and fragrances of 2026, according to beauty editors.

Beauty

Summer is my favorite season. If I could bottle up ...

Makeup tips from beauty expert Nikol Johnson on YouTube.
Common skincare mistakes women over 40 make regarding fine lines.
Haircuts that divert attention from jowls and lift the face.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for health benefits.
Hailey Bieber's haircuts that add thickness to fine hair.
Stylish chiffon nails showcased on Instagram.