Skip to main content
Kim Kardashian at Kering's Caring for Women Dinner.
Kylie Jenner with Stormi and Timothée Chalamet on getaway.
Madonna at the Met Gala in stunning outfit.

Beauty

A Makeup Artist Warns That Woman Over 40 Should Never Use These Eyeshadow Colors—They Instantly Add Years To Your Face

February 11, 2024 by Marissa Matozzo
shefinds | Beauty
Featured image

Enhancing one’s best facial features is no doubt achievable with the use of eyeshadow. It even has the ability to give a youthful appearance when applied in accordance with one’s eye shape, color and skin tone. We caught up with seasoned makeup artists and professionals who shared their timeless tips on eyeshadow application.

They also provided insight on two unflattering eyeshadow shades that women over 40 should avoid, as well as two trendy alternatives that are sure to impress! Read on for tips, suggestions and insight from Kerrin Jackson, celebrity, film and television makeup artist and creator of The Makeup Refinery blog and Christina-Lauren Pollack, creator and lifestyle editor at Inspirations & Celebrations.

 

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
Image from SHEfinds

2 Unflattering Eyeshadow Shades To Skip Over 40

1. Skip Fiery Reds

One eye makeup color Jackson suggests skipping if you want to look younger or more awake is a red, scarlet or crimson one. "Red eyeshadows can add years to your face simply by making your eyes look tired, irritated and generally giving a look of being unwell," she explains. There is "very little" that is flattering about a red eyeshadow, Jackson stresses, and she always recommends "avoiding red on the eyes altogether."

"I generally avoid red eyeshadow because it is such a tricky shade to get right on the eyes," Jackson continues. This, she says, is purely because of the "color of our blood," which is red, of course. "What happens when we cry, or have an allergic reaction to something, rub our eyes, or get a bruise? Our skin and eyes go red," she continues. This, she says, is why using a red eyeshadow can inadvertently look like "you have been crying, have allergies or something unpleasant altogether is going on. It’s not a very appealing or flattering look."

Image from SHEfinds

Instead, Try Nude Shades

One eyeshadow tip that Pollack says she recommends for women over 40 is to apply a light matte nude shade all over the eyelid. "For example, if you have fair skin, an ivory-colored shadow is ideal; whereas, if you have darker skin, you can opt for a mocha hue," Pollack says.

"Matte eyeshadows are great for age 40+ skin, as they don't make fine lines look pronounced (whereas sparkly shadows can). Plus, it gives you a natural, refreshed appearance that makes you look more awake and bright-eyed."

Image from SHEfinds

2 Skip Metallics

As seen on Euphoria, BeautyTok and elsewhere, "metallics are back," Jackson says, and "for us over 40s, that may not be such good news anymore." A shimmery red eyeshadow, she adds, can be "particularly cruel to even the most slightly textured skin."

Due to the light-reflecting flakes or ingredients in many shimmer products, this kind of eyeshadow can "end up highlighting every wrinkle, line or textured surface you usually spend your makeup time trying to soften," Jackson warns.

Image from SHEfinds

Instead, Try Neutral Mattes

As a celebrity makeup artist, Jackson says she ultimately "avoids metallic eyeshadows on older skin because shimmers and metallics are so harsh on textured and wrinkled complexions."They can "cause lines and wrinkles to look more pronounced" than they actually are, she continues. Jackson goes on to note that the best bet is to "avoid these products and stick with neutral mattes instead."

"If you must use a shimmer eye shadow, try a cream-based product that you can blend in softly," she concludes. This will be "far more flattering and flexible on your skin" than a powdery metallic or shimmery eyeshadow. Got it!

Author:

Former Senior Staff Writer

Marissa is a Brooklyn-based journalist and former senior staff writer at SheFinds, specializing in pop culture, entertainment, and lifestyle topics. She crafted engaging, SEO-driven content on celebrity style, entertainment news, beauty trends, and wellness. Her work, including red carpet coverage and features on fashion, music, film, and NYC culture, has appeared in PAPER Magazine, Paste Magazine, The Knockturnal, Bandsintown, and more. When not writing, you can find her with her nose in a great book, at an indie concert, vintage shopping or visiting the best coffeeshops in NYC.

Summer's viral Italian bob hairstyle trend showcased on a model.
Woman applying concealer for a flawless makeup look.
Six beauty habits that may cause skin inflammation explained.
Older woman enjoying a skincare routine for healthy skin.
Person sipping spearmint tea for relaxation and wellness.
Common hair mistakes that could be aging you, according to stylists.
Group discussing anti-aging skincare tips and products.
Best foundation types for mature skin to minimize fine lines.
Trendy butterfly haircut featured on Instagram by stylist Alex.
Fresh haircuts for women to look polished and modern in 2026.
Pouring shampoo into hand for a clean hair routine.
Everyday habits that may accelerate collagen breakdown.
Shutterstock image related to celebrity beauty trends.
Best summer scents and fragrances of 2026, according to beauty editors.
YouTube makeup tips by Nikol Johnson for flawless looks.
Common skincare mistakes women over 40 make, highlighting fine lines.
Haircuts that subtly lift the face and distract from jowls.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for health benefits.
Hailey Bieber's hairstyles that add volume to fine hair.
Chiffon nail design showcased on Instagram by Iram Shelton.
Summer's viral Italian bob hairstyle trend showcased on a model.
Woman applying concealer for a flawless makeup look.
Six beauty habits that may cause skin inflammation explained.
Older woman enjoying a skincare routine for healthy skin.
Person sipping spearmint tea for relaxation and wellness.
Common hair mistakes that could be aging you, according to stylists.
Group discussing anti-aging skincare tips and products.
Best foundation types for mature skin to minimize fine lines.
Trendy butterfly haircut featured on Instagram by stylist Alex.
Fresh haircuts for women to look polished and modern in 2026.
Pouring shampoo into hand for a clean hair routine.
Everyday habits that may accelerate collagen breakdown.
Shutterstock image related to celebrity beauty trends.
Best summer scents and fragrances of 2026, according to beauty editors.

Beauty

Summer is my favorite season. If I could bottle up ...

YouTube makeup tips by Nikol Johnson for flawless looks.
Common skincare mistakes women over 40 make, highlighting fine lines.
Haircuts that subtly lift the face and distract from jowls.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for health benefits.
Hailey Bieber's hairstyles that add volume to fine hair.
Chiffon nail design showcased on Instagram by Iram Shelton.