Skip to main content
"Banana nice cream"
"Costco strawberries in a box"
"Costco Kirkland toilet paper"

Homepage

Costco Shoppers Share The Items They Would Never Buy Because They're 'Not A Good Deal' And 'Bad' Quality: Toilet Paper, More

July 7, 2025 by Abigail Connolly
shefinds | Homepage
Featured image

So many people in the country are heavily reliant on Costco, as it’s often a guaranteed store for great deals and bulk items that can help keep families fed. However, even the biggest fans of Costco have bought items that they never want to buy again.

After a Costco shopper asked other members on Reddit about items from the store that are “not a good deal” or are “not good quality,” people flooded the comments section with tips on what food or home items they suggest avoiding. Many wrote that you could find better versions elsewhere, or that the Kirkland brand version is simply not worth it. Read more about six of the items some Costco shoppers say you should “not buy” below.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
"Costco Kirkland batteries"

Strawberries

Costco produce has been a controversial topic for a while now, as due to the bulk nature of their items, customers have found that fresh fruits and vegetables don't last as long as smaller packages at other stores would. Under a Reddit post about Costco items not to buy, several shoppers shared negative comments about their strawberries specifically.

 

"[Their] strawberries seem to grow mold on the way home," wrote a shopper.

 

"We don't get the produce anymore because it goes so ridiculously bad, which sucks because Costco used to have the best strawberries," added another.

"Emma Stone at Annual Actor Awards"

Kirkland Toilet Paper

Toilet paper is one of those items where you don't want to skimp on quality if you don't have to. While getting Costco's Kirkland brand toilet paper in bulk may seem like a good deal, shoppers advise against it, as it doesn't seem to hold up very well.

 

"Kirkland toilet paper is god awful," wrote a Reddit user.

 

"The Kirkland toilet paper is definitely not the same formula as 5 years ago," added another.

 

Several users wrote that the toilet paper was too thin, left behind debris, and that it was a better idea to buy name-brand instead.

"Salma Hayek at 12th Annual Breakthrough Prize Ceremony"

Kirkland Chicken Breasts

One would think that getting a basic item like fresh chicken breasts from a place like Costco would be great, but as it turns out, several customers had complaints about the store's poultry quality.

 

"[The] chicken breasts are not the best and expensive," wrote a Costco customer.

 

"They're all gigantic Frankenstein chickens and [they're] woody," added another.

 

Another shopper who said they "never" buy the chicken from Costco wrote, "I don't think it's good quality chicken."

"Collagen boosting superfoods"

Bananas

Like their strawberries, Costco's bananas are another produce item that has disappointed their members several times. Bananas are typically a very accessible piece of produce, but at the massive retailer, it isn't a guarantee you'll be able to find great or ripe ones.

 

"They have better Bananas at Walmart," commented a shopper.

 

Another customer wrote that the store is often full of "green bananas that never ripen, despite them being the cheapest product in the store."

"Middle-aged woman drinking wine"

Blueberry Muffins

The bakery section at Costco is one of the most beloved things about the store amongst customers, as they're consistently churning out freshly baked goods that can be used for all different kinds of events. However, some items from the bakery aren't very popular, especially the muffins.

 

"Costco is cutting corners on quality left and right," observed an angry shopper. "The blueberry muffins have changed [in] quality."

 

"The muffins are tasteless and super boring," commented another.

 

"The blueberry ones are the worst."

"Best Prime Day beauty deals on Amazon"

Kirkland Batteries

If you are looking to stock up on your supply of batteries, Costco members advise against the Kirkland ones. There have been several issues with leaks, short lifespan, and more, leading shoppers to realize they're not worth it.

 

"I have found Kirkland batteries in the past handful of years not to last very long," wrote a member.

 

"Many fresh ones are dead when replaced in whatever electronic I need replacing in, too."

 

"They are the worst I have ever bought," noted another.

 

"You leave them in too long, and they leak and corrode. They are worse than inexpensive Amazon batteries."

 

Did any of these items surprise you?

Author:

Editorial Assistant

Abigail is a journalist based in Brooklyn, New York. As an Editorial Assistant for SheFinds, she covers topics ranging from celebrity news and fashion to wellness. She has written for other publications, including Chip Chick, Bandsintown, BroadwayWorld, and more. When she isn't writing, Abigail loves spending time in the city with her friends, being a 'dog mom' to her Chihuahua, and singing along to some of her favorite music.

"Ariana Grande at Golden Globes"
"Kylie Jenner at Met Gala 2025"
"Woman applying sunscreen"
"Taylor Swift with Travis Kelce"
"Seeds not pastries"
"Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner"
"Bad Bunny at the Grammys"
"iPhone charging plugged into laptop"
"iPhone charging showing settings"
"Viral Italian bob hair trend for summer"
"Angelina Jolie at The Trophee Chopard Award"
"Selena Gomez at Rare Impact Fund Benefit"
"Pool lounger cocktail trail mix"
"Brad Pitt and Ines de Ramon at F1 World Premiere"
"Queen Camilla and Prince Harry and Meghan Markle"
Angelina Jolie receiving the Trophee Chopard Award.
Selena Gomez at the 3rd Annual Rare Impact Fund Benefit.
Pool lounger with cocktail and trail mix from Aldi.
Brad Pitt and Ines de Ramon at the F1 World Premiere.
Queen Camilla, Prince Harry, and Meghan Markle together.
Emma Stone at the Annual Actor Awards ceremony.
Salma Hayek at the 12th Annual Breakthrough Prize Ceremony.
Collagen-boosting superfoods for glowing summer skin.
Middle-aged woman enjoying a glass of wine.
Best Prime Day beauty deals on Amazon right now.

Beauty

Prime Day is basically a holiday for anyone who's ...

Ariana Grande attending the Golden Globes ceremony.
Kylie Jenner showcasing black style at the 2025 Met Gala.
Woman applying sunscreen for sun protection.
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce together at an event.
Seeds as a healthier alternative to pastries.
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner posing for a photo.
Bad Bunny performing at the Grammy Awards.
iPhone charging plugged into a laptop for power.
iPhone charging settings displayed on the screen.
The viral Italian bob hairstyle trending this summer.
Angelina Jolie receiving the Trophee Chopard Award.
Selena Gomez at the 3rd Annual Rare Impact Fund Benefit.
Pool lounger with cocktail and trail mix from Aldi.
Brad Pitt and Ines de Ramon at the F1 World Premiere.
Queen Camilla, Prince Harry, and Meghan Markle together.