Skip to main content
Modern workspace with a person typing on a laptop.
Chic haircuts for women over 50 trending in 2026.
Donald Trump speaking at a maternal healthcare event.

Beauty

The Biggest Eyeshadow Mistakes Women Over 40 With Mature Eyelids Make That Look 'Heavy And Drawn Down'

March 29, 2025 by Lisa Cupido
shefinds | Beauty
Featured image

There are times when you think you’re doing everything right in your makeup look. After all, it’s the same eye makeup that you perfected all of those years ago, and you’re not about to change course now!

But here’s the reality: our features change over time, even if slightly. It is common for eyelids to become more hooded with age (and some of us were born with this beautiful feature). So lining our eyes and using certain eyeshadow shades or techniques can cause mature eyes to look “heavy and drawn down,” according to one makeup artist, who posted a helpful video about this on TikTok:

@katetalbertmua

The Biggest Eyeshadow Mistakes for Mature Eyelids The side by side comparison at the end is pretty wild! As always, if you’re making any of these “mistakes” and loving the results, then please just ignore me!! Makeup is all about feeling like the best version of yourself. ❤️ Products Used: @Rare Beauty Cream Eyeshadow (Shade Integrity) @Persona Cosmetics Identity Eyeshadow Palette @roseandbenbeauty Brush E29 @rephr Brush 27 & 02 #eyemakeuptutorial #makeuptipsandtricks #makeupforall #makeuptechniques #makeupformatureskin #eyeshadows

♬ original sound – Kate

If you are over 40 and have mature eyelids, these are three of the “biggest” mistakes that Kate at katetalbertmua reminding us not to make.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
using-light-eyeshadow-lid

1. Using Light Eyeshadow All Over the Eye

 


A very light, bright eyeshadow applied all over the eyelid draws attention to the lid. This isn’t always the best thing if you have fine lines on your lid or not a lot of lid space. Instead, Kate recommends using a medium brown shade and applying it with a fluffy brush to the center of the lid, working its way outward and upward. “Wherever you put down that brush first is where you’re going to get the biggest payoff in terms of color.”

adding-dark-color-outer-corner-eye

2. Adding a Dark Color to the Outer Lid Corner

 


This tips was in practically every beauty video not long ago: applying a dark eyeshadow to the outer corner is meant to emphasize eyes and make them stand out. But on mature eyes it can droop down the area of the eye that is typically the heaviest for mature women. Instead, use a small and precise brush and place a darker color right along the upper lash line, as close to the lashes as possible.

makeup-artist-applying-eyeshadow

3. Not Adding Luminosity to the Lid

 


You’re missing out on a step that can really brighten your eyes if you aren’t adding luminosity to your lid. We’re not talking about heavy glitter — just a small amount of shimmer on a neutral shade. Place it in the center of the upper lid — it can really make your eyes pop and make them look more alert and refreshed.

Author:

Lisa Fogarty is a lifestyle writer and reporter based in New York who covers health, wellness, relationships, sex, beauty, and parenting.

Woman applying sunscreen for sun protection.
Viral Italian bob haircut trend for summer 2023.
Woman applying concealer in a beauty tutorial.
Common beauty habits causing skin inflammation revealed
Older woman applying skincare routine for healthy skin
Woman enjoying a cup of spearmint tea
Aging hair mistakes stylists caution against for better hair
Arielle Lorre and Anthony Youn discussing anti-aging skincare.
Best foundations for mature skin to reduce fine lines.
Trendy butterfly haircut showcased on Instagram.
Fresh haircuts women are choosing for a modern look.
Pouring shampoo into hand for hair washing routine.
Everyday habits that may harm collagen production.
Close-up of a vibrant food dish with colorful ingredients
Top summer scents and fragrances recommended by beauty editors.
Makeup tips from Nikol Johnson on YouTube.
Common skincare mistakes for women over 40 highlighting fine lines.
Hairstyles that subtly lift the face while drawing attention away from jowls.
Pouring vitamin D drops into a palm for supplementation.
Hailey Bieber's trendy haircuts enhancing fine hair texture.
Woman applying sunscreen for sun protection.
Viral Italian bob haircut trend for summer 2023.
Woman applying concealer in a beauty tutorial.
Common beauty habits causing skin inflammation revealed
Older woman applying skincare routine for healthy skin
Woman enjoying a cup of spearmint tea
Aging hair mistakes stylists caution against for better hair
Arielle Lorre and Anthony Youn discussing anti-aging skincare.
Best foundations for mature skin to reduce fine lines.
Trendy butterfly haircut showcased on Instagram.
Fresh haircuts women are choosing for a modern look.
Pouring shampoo into hand for hair washing routine.
Everyday habits that may harm collagen production.
Close-up of a vibrant food dish with colorful ingredients
Top summer scents and fragrances recommended by beauty editors.

Beauty

Summer is my favorite season. If I could bottle up ...

Makeup tips from Nikol Johnson on YouTube.
Common skincare mistakes for women over 40 highlighting fine lines.
Hairstyles that subtly lift the face while drawing attention away from jowls.
Pouring vitamin D drops into a palm for supplementation.
Hailey Bieber's trendy haircuts enhancing fine hair texture.