Skip to main content
Madonna at the Met Gala in stunning fashion.
Taylor Swift boarding a private jet in 2024.
Woman experiencing fatigue from lack of sleep.

Beauty

Makeup Artists Say You’ve Been Doing Eyeliner All Wrong And It’s Giving You Dark Circles

January 13, 2022 by Marissa Matozzo
shefinds | Beauty
Featured image

The perfect eyeliner cat eye is hard to master, and so is preventing dark eye circles. With age and lack of sleep, dark circles are inevitable for many of us. For many, they are hereditary as well and can be treated over time with dermatologist visits, vitamins, and a consistent skincare routine. 

There might be one eyeliner habit that contributes to them, however, that you can stop now to prevent adding to the darkness under your eyes any further. We spoke to professional makeup artists all about eyeliner mistakes related to eye bags, and how to fix them. 

What can really give you darker under-eyes, experts explain, is removing eyeliner incorrectly, and we’ll get to that. Firstly, we asked experts for common eyeliner mistakes that can make your dark eye circles even more pronounced. 

Common Eyeliner Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Whether you want a sharp wing, 90s smudged waterline or just a subtle pop to your peepers, eyeliner is a powerful tool in countless aesthetics and styles. From ancient royalty to modern rock stars, a kohl-rimmed eye can make an epic statement, that is, if it’s done correctly.  

Too much of a good thing is sometimes a bad thing. Hair and makeup artist Andrea Claire explains that one common eyeliner mistake people with dark circles make is adding more darkness, especially with lining the lower lash line. 

“If you love your liner and have dark circles, keep your liner to the top lash line,” says Claire. A little trick she uses to counter darkness is to apply a nude liner to the lower waterline, which she says helps to “open and brighten the eyes.” 

Makeup artist Gargi Patel explains that preparing your eye area first and foremost is key for fierce eyeliner, and to cover up your under-eyes successfully. “The goal is to always keep the eyeliner in places you want it to stay,” says Patel. “Using a good primer suitable for the eye area will help to keep not only your eyeliner in place, but also your eyeshadow.”

She adds that a primer should also hydrate the eye area so liquid eyeliners will not dry out. 

If you’re worried about eyeliner-related errors causing dark circles rather than emphasizing them, read on for a crucial makeup step you might be doing incorrectly.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!
Winged eyeliner look accentuating under-eye circles.

How Incorrect Removal Affects Dark Circles

 

The only thing that can really cause dark circles when it comes to eyeliner or makeup in general, beauty expert David Gray says, is the removal process. Gray notes that it’s important to use a “really good eye makeup remover,” seeing as the eyes and the skin around them is so sensitive.

 

“What defines a proper remover is that it's quite effortless and doesn't require much rubbing,” says Gray. This, he says, is important because rubbing the skin can cause capillary damage and inflammation, “worsening your dark circles as a result.”

 

When we take off our eyeliner, many people will rub with makeup wipes which can lead to broken capillaries as well as inflammation in the under-eye area, as beauty expert Sanem Ahearn points out.

 

“By switching to some kind of cleanser or balm with a water and oil-based formula, those products will glide right off and prevent any unnecessary rubbing which worsens under-eye circles,” says Ahearn.

 

Dermatologists and beauty experts often recommend forgoing makeup wipes and switching to cleansers for makeup removal, as the former is linked to worsening wrinkles and under-eye bags.

 

Overall, no matter what look you’re going for with your daily eyeliner, it’s important to keep in mind these specific tips if you’re attempting to conceal your under-eyes.

 

Most crucially, taking off your eyeliner matters in decreasing the appearance of dark eye circles, and what you take it off with. Your personal dermatologist can provide more information, as frequent visits are an important part of creating a skincare routine that works for you!

Author:

Former Senior Staff Writer

Marissa is a Brooklyn-based journalist and former senior staff writer at SheFinds, specializing in pop culture, entertainment, and lifestyle topics. She crafted engaging, SEO-driven content on celebrity style, entertainment news, beauty trends, and wellness. Her work, including red carpet coverage and features on fashion, music, film, and NYC culture, has appeared in PAPER Magazine, Paste Magazine, The Knockturnal, Bandsintown, and more. When not writing, you can find her with her nose in a great book, at an indie concert, vintage shopping or visiting the best coffeeshops in NYC.

The viral Italian bob hair trend for summer 2023.
Woman applying concealer in a tutorial by Nina Ubhi.
Beauty habits causing skin inflammation discussed in article.
Older woman performing skincare routine for healthy skin.
Drinking spearmint tea for potential skin benefits.
Hair mistakes that could be aging you, according to stylists.
Anti-aging skincare tips with Arielle Lorre and Dr. Anthony Youn.
Foundation types for mature skin to minimize fine lines.
Butterfly haircut showcased on Instagram by The Studio by Alex.
Fresh haircuts and styles for a polished modern look in 2026.
Pouring shampoo into hand for hair washing routine.
Everyday habits potentially breaking down collagen faster.
Shutterstock image related to beauty and skincare.
Best summer scents and fragrances of 2026 as per beauty editors.
Makeup tips video by Nikol Johnson featuring celebrity looks.
Common skincare mistakes for women over 40 highlighted.
Hairstyles that subtly lift the face and distract from jowls.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for supplementation.
Hailey Bieber's haircuts for thicker-looking fine hair.
Instagram photo of stylish chiffon nails by Iram Shelton.
The viral Italian bob hair trend for summer 2023.
Woman applying concealer in a tutorial by Nina Ubhi.
Beauty habits causing skin inflammation discussed in article.
Older woman performing skincare routine for healthy skin.
Drinking spearmint tea for potential skin benefits.
Hair mistakes that could be aging you, according to stylists.
Anti-aging skincare tips with Arielle Lorre and Dr. Anthony Youn.
Foundation types for mature skin to minimize fine lines.
Butterfly haircut showcased on Instagram by The Studio by Alex.
Fresh haircuts and styles for a polished modern look in 2026.
Pouring shampoo into hand for hair washing routine.
Everyday habits potentially breaking down collagen faster.
Shutterstock image related to beauty and skincare.
Best summer scents and fragrances of 2026 as per beauty editors.

Beauty

Summer is my favorite season. If I could bottle up ...

Makeup tips video by Nikol Johnson featuring celebrity looks.
Common skincare mistakes for women over 40 highlighted.
Hairstyles that subtly lift the face and distract from jowls.
Pouring vitamin D into palm for supplementation.
Hailey Bieber's haircuts for thicker-looking fine hair.
Instagram photo of stylish chiffon nails by Iram Shelton.