Don't miss the latest SheFinds newsletter.

Get the very best deals, product reviews, trends and news right to your inbox.


5 Anastasia Brow Pencil Dupes That Will Give You Perfect Brows

September 13, 2017 by Lisa Fogarty
shefinds | beauty

Everyone wants perfect brows that suit their face shape, open their eyes, and actually make it possible to get away with wearing less makeup every day. And one of the most famous names in brows is Anastasia Beverly Hills. The legendary brand started from humble beginnings — one woman with one mission: to shape the eyebrows of countless celebrities (and the rest of the world) using her Golden Ratio Eyebrow Shaping Method, which aims to bring proportion and harmony to your face using a few tried-and-true eyebrow sculpting tricks.

Like any great entrepreneur, Anastasia transferred her salon skills to cosmetics. Her line of bestselling eyebrow products include colored brow pomade, brow powder, a clear brow gel to keep stray hairs in place, and what is arguably considered her most simple, yet effective product: the Anastasia Perfect Brow Pencil. This award-winning tool is a dual-ended pencil that creates long, straight strokes and comes in an impressive eight shades (the other end of the stick features a spoolie). It’s amazing, it’s perfect — but it can also be expensive or difficult to get your hands on.

And that’s where these five incredible Anastasia Brow pencil dupes come in — each one is just as good as the original, according to their many fans.

1) NYX Micro Brow Pencil

NYX brow pencil

It isn’t always easy to find brow products in shades that actually match your brow hair — but it’s dead simple with NYX Micro Brown Pencil’s collection, which comes in eight hues that include ash brown, auburn, and taupe for blondes. These dual-sided pencils also feature a spoolie on one end for easy grooming and reviewers love how the thin pencil easily applies color right on your skin so that brows look natural. This “draws on smoothly,” according to one reviewer on Ulta and “stays on all day without looking greasy, fading, or smearing.”

2) Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil

Benefit brow

Another dual-sided brow pencil, this one from Benefit stands out thanks to a wide base that easily fills in brows and a pointed edge to take care of those stubborn eyebrow tails. The color has been described as soft and buildable so you can choose whether you want a little bit of brow enhancement or bold Cara Delevingne brows. You can choose among six shades that suit everyone from platinum blondes to the darkest brunettes. Fans of the pencil say it goes on smoothly and matches brows to perfection.

3) L’Oreal Brow Stylist Definer

L'Oreal Brow Styler

With an ultra-fine 0.5mm pencil tip, a spoolie on one end, and a mechanical, retractable pencil design, this tool requires no sharpening and adds precise definition to brows. It’s waterproof, which is great for active lifestyles, and reviewers say it’s nearly identical to Anastasia — but costs have the price.

4) Dior Brow Styler

Dior Brow Styler

It’s a bit more expensive, but this luxury brand eyebrow pencil with a retractable pencil and brush provides the most natural and long-lasting coverage ever, according to many reviewers. It’s particularly effective on anyone with sparse brows as you won’t visibly see the pencil strokes between hairs. The unique universal shade works well on light blondes, redheads, and light brunettes — those with darker hair have distinctive shades that are ideal for their coloring.

5) Sephora Retractable Brow Pencil

Sephora retractable eyebrow pencil

A waterproof retractable brow pencil that comes in 10 shades (including Honey Blonde and Soft Charcoal), this dual-sided tool features a wingtip comb tip to brush and blend and a sharp-tipped pencil for precise brush strokes. Reviewers say this really stands up to heat and humidity and is creamy and natural looking.

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


The Super Affordable Shampoo Celebrities Swear By For Thinning Hair

May 21, 2018 by Emily Belfiore
Your hair will thank you for this!


This Eye Cream Is SO Good It Keeps Selling Out At Target

May 21, 2018 by Jessica Harrington
And it's affordable!


This Night Cream Is SO Good It Has A 5-Star Rating At Sephora

May 20, 2018 by Emily Belfiore
It's going to change your life.


This Eye Cream Works SO Fast It Keeps Selling Out At Sephora

May 19, 2018 by Emily Belfiore
Trust us, it's THAT GOOD!


This Is The Best Light Pink Nail Polish That Looks Amazing Year Round

May 18, 2018 by Brianna Peters
Pretty in pink!


Here's Where You Can Buy The MAC Cosmetics X Puma Sneaker Collection

May 18, 2018 by Jennifer Hussein
We'll take every pair!


6 Concealers Every Woman Over 40 Should Be Using

May 18, 2018 by Jessica Harrington
These are life-changing.


Here's What Your Wrinkles Mean: The Reason For Crow's Feet, Smile Lines & More

May 17, 2018 by Lisa Fogarty
Here's how to treat them.


OleHenriksen's New Face Mask Is The Prettiest Thing We've Ever Seen

May 17, 2018 by Emily Belfiore
It's THAT Good!


This Foundation Is SO Good It Has A 5-Star Review On Sephora

May 17, 2018 by Emily Belfiore
It'll blow your mind!


Here's Where You Can Still Buy Marc Jacobs' Sold Out Coconut Bronzer

May 16, 2018 by Jessica Harrington
Just in time for summer!


These Are The 5 Best Shampoos For Colored Hair To Keep It Looking Vibrant & Fresh

May 16, 2018 by Brianna Peters
Lather, rinse and repeat!


This Year's Urban Decay Memorial Day Sale Is Too Good To Pass Up

May 16, 2018 by Jessica Harrington
Who's ready to shop?