How To Talk To Your Boyfriend About Getting Engaged

August 22, 2016 by Justine Schwartz
shefinds | Weddings

Everybody feels differently about marriage. On one end of the spectrum you have people who are so enthusiastic about it that they have the whole thing planned out on Pinterest, down to the centerpieces (and sometimes, when they’re still single). On the other end, you have the Brad and Angelinas and Kurt and Goldies of the world, who are totally in love but couldn’t care less about making it official.

If you’re in a committed relationship, you should at one point have “the talk” about marriage. Do you both believe in it, and do you want to do it together, and when? Most healthy couples do talk about marriage before there’s an actual ring involved, but it can be a tricky subject and awkward at times to navigate. Here’s how to do it so you both feel good about it:

Establish–do you want to marry him? You need to find the answer to this question within yourself, and not from any relatives or close friends–or even from him. Pressure of any kind–financial, peer, societal–is not a good reason to get married. Ask yourself: is this the person I want to grow old with (or at least try to)? Do I want to get married for the right reasons? If there’s no doubt in your mind that you want to get married because you love this person the most, then it’s a good time to broach the topic with him. If you have doubts of any kind, speak with a professional or someone you know who gives solid advice about it.

Start soft. How you initiate the conversation makes all the difference in the world. Something along the lines of, “I’ve thought about spending my life with you,” should work (that’s a pretty earnest approach–if you have a more playful relationship, feel free to inject some humor in it).

READ MORE: 4 Mistakes Couples Make Before Getting Engaged

Come from a place of love. Telling your boyfriend that you want to spend the rest of your life with him should be a romantic conversation–not a contentious one. Don’t stoop to ultimatums, threats or guilt-trips–which are unhealthy forms of communicating for any couple on any topic (not just the marriage one). Speak your truth and be open to hearing his.

Never say never. When communicating, you shouldn’t use absolute phrases like “never” and “always”–it will put him on the defensive. This is just a good ole fashioned rule of relationships.

Don’t assume that he wants to get married. If there’s a reason why he might have certain doubts about marriage (if he’s been divorced before or if he had a bad childhood experience with divorce) be sensitive to that. Don’t expect that marriage is an obvious choice for all people–he might have something different in mind for a lifelong partnership. Start with the fact that you want to love and support him for the long run, then move on to establishing whether you both feel good about the institution of marriage.

Establish a general timeline. Once you’ve agreed that you both want to do this thing, you should discuss a rough timeline for the engagement and the wedding that you are both comfortable with. Are there milestones you want to hit before or after getting engaged or married (graduating from school, buying a house, traveling the world, having a milestone birthday)? Just because you want to get married before 30, doesn’t mean you can force it. Be considerate of his wants and needs. This is good practice for your future marriage, where compromise is key.

Don’t bring it up again. After you’ve determined that you want to marry each other and generally when you want to do it, it’s time to back off. He needs time and space to plan a proposal that you can both truly feel great about–there should still be an element of surprise to the whole thing even though you know it’s coming. He’ll have a lot on his mind between your conversation about marriage and the actual proposal (getting the ring, asking your parents for permission if he’s traditional like that, planning the proposal itself). Let the man do his thing!

READ MORE: 10 Things To Do As Soon As You Get Engaged


Editorial Director

Justine Schwartz is a veteran women's lifestyle editor; she's written extensively about style & beauty tips, health advice and wedding planning for more than a decade. Her work has appeared in New York Magazine, Huffington Post and New York Weddings. Justine has been with SheFinds since 2010; you can reach her via email at [email protected]

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...

From Our Partners

Learn more about RevenueStripe...


How To Create A Wedding Registry Without Breaking Up

Choosing the items you want in your first home together ...


Are You A Bad Bridesmaid? Take The Quiz

It can be stressful being in a wedding. You're ...


8 Wedding Planners Reveal Their Favorite Wedding Detail Ever

From flowers and favors to cakes and decor, wedding planners ...


The 7 Biggest Myths About Winter Weddings

When it comes to weddings, winter often gets a bad ...


11 Things A Bride Should Never Say To Her Bridesmaids

Sure, it’s an honor to be a part of ...


Something Blue's That Don't Suck: Sky High Pumps, Sexy Lingerie & Jewelry That Pops

When you hear "something blue", do you picture something tired, ...


The 10 Best Places To Get Married in Winter

While it might be cold outside, there’s no reason ...


11 Mistakes Brides Make Right After Getting Engaged

You get engaged and you get more than a little ...


12 Creative Ways To Announce Your Engagement

He asked the question and you said "Yes!" Now you ...


The Dos And Donts Of Planning A Bridal Shower

If you’re taking on the task of planning the ...


11 Ways To Save On Your Winter Wedding

While saying I do in the winter comes with its ...